Hay-on-Wye lies on the Welsh side of the Wales and England border in the county of Powys. It proudly claims the title of the world’s first ‘town of books’. As a bibliophile, I become vexed when people say it has become anachronistic, time-worn, or past its sell-by date. I’ve long seen similar critiques of books themselves, amid predictions of their demise due to the growth of the e-book market.
Yet in 2022, UK print book sales increased by 2%, while e-book sales declined by 10%. In 2023, the printed book market sold 767.4mn units. The number of independent bookshops rose from 867 to 1,063, halting a 20-year decline. The Booksellers Association says their resurgence proves they are valued members of high street communities. Though, like all independent retailers, they face ongoing challenges like inflation, energy costs, and labour shortages.
Hard times
Hay wasn’t always Hay-on-Wye; the name was adopted in 1955 because too many letters addressed to Hoy in the Orkneys kept arriving. Some confusion continues, as Royal Mail thinks it better to use the English county of Herefordshire (not to be confused with Hertfordshire) in Hay addresses, rather than Powys, even now.
Secondhand bookshops in Hay-on-Wye have diminished since their zenith in the 1980s and 1990s. But 28 remain today and compete against the biggest multinational booksellers.
Still, the economic climate is challenging, with rising rates and rentals eating into profit margins. Add to this competition from supermarkets offering ‘bestseller’ books at knock-down prices, the expansion of charity shops selling used books, the increase in online shopping, and the cost of living crisis. Physical books remain popular but independent booksellers face a difficult and uncertain future.

There’s no longer a level playing field for book sales. High street shops pay rates and tax from profits, while companies like Amazon use international tax schemes to minimise liabilities. There are major discrepancies between what the UK Government receives in corporate tax from such companies and their many billions in sales, while booksellers who place stock on Amazon and other online marketplaces must pay hefty sales commissions.
Economic trends come and go. In the early 1960s, rural decline was widespread throughout the UK. Road construction tended to isolate the small rural town of Hay-on-Wye rather than connect it with its region. Young people moved further afield for work. The railway station and cinema closed, adding to the growing malaise. The remaining population were more likely to shop in new supermarkets in nearby larger towns. Shops of all sorts in Hay-on-Wye were shutting at a horrifying rate. Property prices were in a downward spiral there as in other rural communities in Wales.
Cometh the King
The arrival of Richard GW Booth – the self-appointed ‘King of Hay’ – on the scene helped to restore the town’s fortunes. Booth had a passion for books, and was left an inheritance by his grandfather that funded his early incursions into the book trade. He learnt quickly and started purchasing books, from single volumes to whole libraries.
In the early 1960s, universities and other institutions were moving away from the classics. Booth easily acquired the contents of the Archbishop of Cardiff’s library, Bala College Library, working men’s and country house libraries, and collections from Australia, Canada, and the USA. By 1983, the Guinness Book of Records described him as “the world’s largest secondhand bookseller”, with a stock of 900,000 to 1,100,000 books.

Booth cherry-picked books from this vast store, selling some at a good profit to other dealers and new universities like that at York. As his stock grew so did his property portfolio, in the form of shops and storage. He first purchased the former fire station in Castle Street, and an agricultural warehouse that he turned into the Richard Booth Bookshop. He then acquired Hay Castle and the former cinema – which held 250,000 books – and a batch of other shops. Other bookshop purchasers followed his lead, rapidly expanding the town.
An unabashed self-publicist, on April Fool’s day 1977 Booth donned a homemade crown, and marched through the town declaring himself to be the King of Hay. In time his example established a ‘town of books’ that attracted visitors from far and wide, developing a kingdom with a solid economic foundation for Hay-on-Wye.
Woodstock of the mind
Booth wasn’t without his critics. He was an eccentric leader with an anarchic attitude who despised government, big business, quangos, tourism organisations, and academia. He was an exponent of preserving the rural economy and traditional crafts and ways of life, and suspicious of technological change.
But Booth’s unconventional brand led to a ‘book town’ movement emulated in other parts of the world. And Hay-on-Wye being the first ‘town of books’ partly spurred the Florence family to stage the inaugural Hay Festival in 1988. This consisted of 33 events held at various locations around the town, with a focus on literature and ideas. It only grew from there, and is now globally esteemed.

In 2001, former US President Bill Clinton described the festival as a “Woodstock of the mind”. In 2023 it held 530 events featuring 890 artists. Research in 2018 showed that the Hay Festival had contributed £70mn over three years to the local economy, £25.8mn in 2018 alone.
The sword of Damocles
The closure of many independent bookshops in the UK coincided with the emergence of the e-book, viewed by many traders as ‘the sword of Damocles’. At the time, I was interested in how some book traders survived while others folded. Obviously, business models and locations varied. But a number of successful businesses outlined the strategies they used to remain profitable.
- Combining the bookshop with another business, such as an ice cream parlour. Others sold goods like chocolates, cards, CDs, and DVDs (at the time). The point is not the items but having other ways to generate income.
- Appealing to diverse demographics and working within the local community. For example, supplying books to local schools and colleges.
- Focussing on the shop’s interior and ambience, trading knowledge, and the customer experience, ensuring the premises were welcoming, well-lit, and airy, with the books accessible and attractively displayed.
- Connecting with literary events. In one instance, a bookshop had a presence at three local festivals.
- Specialising in a niche market, such as children’s books or graphic novels.
- Forming partnerships with organisations dedicated to literacy. Such booksellers emphasised the importance of responding to change, and revising and updating their business model to suit the times.
Looking at current bookshops in Hay-on-Wye, I don’t see the apocalyptic future many might predict. Recent arrivals like North Bookshop, Green Ink Booksellers, Hay Castle Bookshop, and Gay-on-Wye are determined and set to buck any negative trends. They embrace a contemporary feel, bringing light, air, and space into their premises, enhancing the browsing and buying experience. I’m fairly sure they’ll do well in the coming years, despite the obstacles, given the healthy sales market for books.
Zen and the art of bookshop maintenance
Those endeavours stand in contrast to a few other general bookshops I visited in Hay-on-Wye, which appear frozen in time. They may have to watch out. The layout and the way books were displayed seemed unchanged, with every case, shelf, nook, cranny, and even floor space crammed with jumbled heaps of books.
While it’s a style that’s charming in films and delights some browsers, it does little to attract many actual buyers or promote what’s on offer. Poor signage, layout, and use of space create barriers and can be overwhelming for the customer. In my case, this hastened my rapid departure, with the old adage ‘less is more’ ringing in my head.
Vendors such as Murder and Mayhem, The Poetry Bookshop, The Children’s Bookshop, and others in Hay-on-Wye concentrate successfully on niche markets. Others choose to diversify, combining more than one business under the same roof.

Richard Booth’s Bookshop on Lion Street extends over three floors and is managed by specialist department heads. It sells new, secondhand, and antiquarian books, and a large range of gifts, games, puzzles, stationery, quality craft materials, and yarn. There’s even a luxurious cinema with leather seats, a reception area, and a bar.
The Old Electric Shop is another example of diversification – a bookshop, coffee shop, and purveyor of new and vintage furniture and gifts. It also hosts musical events and sometimes operates as a cocktail bar. These are by no means all of the bookshops in Hay-on-Wye, but offer examples of the breadth and resilience of trade there. And, of course, having the huge annual festival helps a great deal.
Long live Hay-on-Wye
I made other observations during my recent trip to Hay-on-Wye. There’s a growing trend towards what I call hybrid bookstores, selling both secondhand and new books. There are shops with a complementary relationship to the book trade like The Black Mountains Bindery, a traditional bookbinder, and Bartrums & Co Ltd, which provides fine writing tools and stationery from all over the world.
I also noted a movement towards ‘gentrification’. Booth is probably turning in his grave at the London-style clothes shops that have sprung up, as Hay-on-Wye has become a go-to destination. Add to this the growth of restaurants, cafes, antiques and music shops, and art galleries. The town continues to transform into an interdependent economic community, with the bookshops as its bedrock. Remarkable for a town with a population of around 2,000.

Its quirky nature still exists for me. You only have to look at the castle, which has stood for 900 years – presenting itself as a castle on one side and a Jacobean mansion on the other. It even has its own currency, the Hay voucher, available at Pughs at Londis, 2 High Town. And the shop fronts are so untypical of those you’d find on any other high street, adding to the town’s offbeat nature.
So the visitor’s experience is unique and there’s always something special to be found. When searching for a book in Hay-on-Wye, I always find that the book chooses me rather than the other way round. It’s a kind of adventure you only seem to experience there, in a somewhat liminal space. The Marcher borderland mentality persists among its people, who jealously guard their (retail) independence in this self-professed kingdom, perhaps watched over by the stubborn, book-loving spirit of the King of Hay.







