Devolved nations are making differing levels of progress on empowering communities to own land once again. Should those communities be open to the idea of allowing hunting on land that comes into their ownership?
This may seem a straightforward question with a simple yes-or-no answer. But it carries with it a plethora of cultural, historical, social justice, animal rights, and biodiversity implications.
Forest law
The film Wilding tells the story of the rewilding of the Knepp Estate in Sussex. But it doesn’t touch upon two things about the history of that land – how the family involved came to own it in the first place, and the role hunting has played in both its creation and its current management.
Historical records for the estate go back to the 12th century, when Knepp Castle was used as a hunting lodge at the heart of a thousand-acre ‘deer park’. The Normans created deer parks by taking large areas of common land and placing them under ‘forest law’. This forbade the hunting, harvesting, foraging, and other activities previously enjoyed by commoners.
Six centuries later, Knepp was purchased by Sir Charles Raymond, and has descended through the Burrell family ever since. Over the centuries, the land was broken up for agricultural use. But, controversially, the historical ties with the tradition of an exclusive right to hunt have been maintained.
Rights in common
Hunting for subsistence is a far more ancient and equitable right of land access than the example of Knepp. Under both Anglo-Saxon law and the laws of Hywel Dda, commoners held rights in common. These included the right to hunt wild animals on common land to feed and clothe their families and communities, while living sustainably.
Such rights have been fought over through hundreds of years of enclosures of land, even until the present day. Our current laws around who can hunt what and where are a product of this long history. It’s a story of the struggle between a shared right to subsist in and from the landscape, and the right to hunt to the exclusion of all others.
Poverty alleviation is a core founding purpose of many community organisations, as is social justice. So should such organisations allow – even if only in principle – community members to hunt on land they have secured, in order that they may subsist?
Questions for commoners
On the other hand, with nature and biodiversity crises being so pressing, would permission to hunt – even to stave off hunger – place an intolerable strain on our already depleted wildlife? Even putting animal welfare concerns aside? And if so, where does that leave activities such as foraging, harvesting, gleaning, and panning?
These are the kinds of questions and responsibilities our communities once successfully managed as commoners. And they’re the kinds of questions we’ll need to get used to asking again, as ever more communities seek to secure land for community use.







