On Saturday 10 October, demonstrators gathered at the Maes (Castle Square) in Caernarfon to oppose a proposed AI data centre on the former Ferodo site, between Caernarfon and y Felinheli. Following speeches by politicians, residents and environmentalists, they marched around the castle to the county hall. The protest followed a well-attended community meeting that demonstrated the strength of local opposition. A petition against the development has already attracted 22,000 signatures.
The scale of the proposal
An outline planning application for a data processing facility on the brownfield site and adjoining greenfield land has prompted renewed local concern. Submitted to Gwynedd County Council, the proposal includes demolishing the existing buildings and structures. Campaign group “Gwarchod y Menai” (Safeguard the Menai) opposes the plans and says the largest building would be 100ft high. The proposed complex would occupy more than 50 football pitches on the shores of the Menai Strait, extending beyond the original brownfield site. Campaigners also say the site still contains asbestos that could be released into the surrounding environment during construction or landscaping.
Ferodo was a major local employer in the second half of the twentieth century. From 1962 to 1997, up to 1,500 workers produced brake pads, linings and other components for the automotive industry. The business later became Friction Dynamics, and the factory closed in 2008, leaving a large brownfield site.
The developer’s case
Developer Gwelyfenai Ltd, which submitted the planning application, says the project would create jobs and help regenerate the derelict site. Reports prepared on the company’s behalf describe its vision as a highly sustainable digital infrastructure facility that would strengthen Wales’s data and technology capabilities while responding sensitively to the site’s environmental and landscape setting. The developer says concerns raised about other data centres do not apply to Canolfan Ddata Menai. It argues that the project would boost the economy and that its cooling system would recirculate water rather than continually draw on supplies. The company says construction would support 700 workers and that the completed facility would employ about 200 people. However, many residents believe the benefits would not remain local because specialist construction workers and permanent staff would be recruited from outside the area.
Political pushback
Liz Saville Roberts, Plaid Cymru MP for Dwyfor Meirionnydd, said in letters to this publication and concerned constituents that the proposed 57-football-pitch complex represented a major change to the Menai Strait landscape and therefore required the highest level of scrutiny and public engagement. She added that local opposition was growing and that residents’ concerns were widely shared.

She also questioned whether the claimed employment benefits would justify the development. Saville Roberts said that developers needed to demonstrate clear, lasting benefits for local communities, given doubts that the number of permanent jobs would justify the project’s scale. She argued that concerns about site contamination, water demand, the loss of agricultural land, and wider environmental and landscape impacts outweighed the uncertain economic returns.
Beca Brown, Plaid Cymru MS for Gwynedd Maldwyn, added: “The strength of feeling locally about this proposal is clear. Residents have raised legitimate concerns about the scale of the development, its environmental impact, and the pressure it could place on local resources. Having considered the views put forward by the community, I share those concerns and oppose the proposal.” At the time of writing, the two local Reform MSs had not responded to Bylines Cymru’s invitation to comment.
A unique habitat at risk
At Saturday’s meeting, Frankie Hobro of Anglesey Sea Zoo, which lies directly opposite the proposed site, said: “The development would border several Sites of Special Scientific Interest and Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty, and would be adjacent to a Special Area of Conservation designated for environmental protection. Protected wildlife in the immediate area includes otters, grey seals, lamprey, and several species of migratory fish and birds. The Menai Strait is unique globally and, if this data centre goes ahead, it will completely and permanently destroy this unique and irreplaceable global phenomenon.”

Local Anglesey residents whose homes overlook the Menai Straits and the mountains of Eryri also express concern. Many feel it would be a blight on the landscape and diminish the visual beauty of the area. Noise and the smell would also cause a nuisance.
Campaigners have warned that the proposed data centre could make reopening the former Bangor–Caernarfon railway more difficult and expensive unless its route is protected. The campaign group, Traws Link Cymru has objected to the redevelopment because the former railway alignment runs through the site. In a letter to Gwynedd County Council, the group said that retaining the Lôn Las Menai walking and cycling route, which follows the old railway, would not in itself safeguard the land for future rail services.
In summary, objectors argue that the development’s uncertain employment benefits do not justify its potential costs: disruption during construction, pressure on water and electricity supplies, pollution and noise, damage to wildlife and the marine environment, loss of local amenities, and the obstruction of future rail services.
Have your say
Members of the public, as well as concerned organisations, are invited to submit their views on the project by 17th October to Gwynedd County Council’s planning department. The planning reference number is C25/0740/20/EIA or alternatively email cynllunio@gwynedd.llyw.cymru.
More from Gareth Wyn Roberts

Bylines Network Gazette is out!
The latest Bylines Network Gazette is out now. Become a Friend of Bylines Network or upgrade to a paid Substack subscription, and you will get access to a vital collection of citizen articles and stories.
Journalism by the people, for the people.







