There are few things as prevalent and visibly obvious in Welsh society as austerity and its symptoms are. You only need to look at the state of your community, whether rural or urban – its educational and other community assets, its streets and public transport systems.
It’s all running on a shoestring now, taped together by goodwill and promises. Buildings are in disrepair, budgets in the red, buses delayed, trains cancelled. It’s become the new normal. Many barely bat an eyelid anymore. Political leaders offer us nothing but the cold comfort of managed decline, the cynical lie that this is the best we can hope for. It’s a reality, a narrative, that many in Wales have adopted.
Make Aberdare Great Again
There are people telling a different story, a progressive story of hope and an equitable future for all. Unfortunately, despite caring deeply about those most disenfranchised by austerity, they haven’t yet realised they’re not reaching those who need to hear and feel hope the most. What good is that?
I’ve written previously that the left’s fear of radical change, their reluctance to challenge the status quo, has positioned them as little more than caretakers of a broken system. They’re content to tinker at the edges, playing the role of moderates and being the managers of a declining nation. The UK Labour Government’s facade of ‘Change’ looks increasingly like a practical joke, one they intend that sick, older, and disabled people – and, more recently, students – should pay for.
This betrayal of ideals and abandonment of the most vulnerable by Labour is fuelling the rise of populist politics, across the UK and specifically in Wales, where the government has been a Labour one for nearly 26 years. Welsh people are struggling to feed themselves and their families, heat their homes, pay rent and mortgages, and keep their jobs. They’re crying out for real change. Something. Anything.
Chancers like Nigel Farage have seized upon this very real crisis, using the suffering of others to further their careers. They’re promising a fix and offering up an enemy to hate – the oldest snake oil going. They’ll restore glory to Wales, they say. It’s balderdash, but that doesn’t matter much if you’re out of options, and hope. Of course you want to believe it. You’re desperate.
Systematic strangulation of communities
Austerity in Wales isn’t just an ‘economic policy’; that’s a formal, neutral phrase that glides over and hides a multitude of harms. Austerity is a deliberate act of political neglect, a slow strangulation of working- and even middle-class communities under the guise of fiscal responsibility. It’s imposed from above by people who’ll never feel its bite. Debated endlessly in Westminster by politicians who’ll never have to skip meals to pay their energy bills. (We pay their energy bills).
Those who suffer most are barely included in conversations about how to tackle austerity. They’re blamed, vilified, scapegoated, and gaslit – portrayed as the architects of their own misfortune.
Cuts to welfare, public services, and local authority funding have hit Wales hard, exacerbating decades of deindustrialisation and economic decline. While politicians boast about employment rates and economic recovery, entire communities are left struggling, their high streets filled with shuttered shops and payday loan offices. Food bank use is at an all-time high. In a country that was once a global powerhouse of coal and steel, people work full time yet can’t afford necessities.
The narrative pushed by media and politicians is one of personal failure rather than systemic collapse. If people are out of work, they must be lazy. If they struggle to afford rent? Irresponsible. If they claim benefits, they must be scamming the system.
The realities are less palatable to and convenient for those in power. Wages have stagnated while the cost of living has soared. Public services, from the NHS to local councils, are falling into the chasm between underfunding and increasing demand. The rise in economic inactivity isn’t due to an epidemic of Gen-Z laziness. It’s a result of long-term damage inflicted by austerity, compounded by (ignoring) Covid and long Covid and a crippling mental health crisis.
Scapegoats not solutions
In 2024, 9.4mn people aged 16–64 were considered economically inactive. That’s 22% of the working-age population. It sounds alarming, but the reality is of course more complex.
A large proportion, 26%, are students, learning in the hope of securing better jobs in the future. A further 11.6% are early retirees who’ve managed to escape the grind. Others are carers, looking after family members when social care is stretched to breaking point or invisibility.
And there we get to the real crisis – over 30% of the ‘economically inactive’ are long-term sick. Not ‘lazy’. This is about a healthcare system that’s been stripped to its bones, with waiting lists stretching for years, leaving people sicker and less able to work. All while flu, RSV, norovirus, Covid, whooping cough, and more are allowed to run rampant. (A once-in-a-century pandemic also apparently stripped us of centuries of public health wisdom and best practice).
Yet instead of addressing structural issues, governments focus their ire on so-called “benefits scroungers”. In 2024, disability benefit claimants UK-wide numbered around 3mn, with some claiming due to mental health conditions. That’s around 4% of the population, costing a theoretical maximum of £20.7bn annually. It’s pocket change compared to the £219bn lost to financial crime and tax evasion.
But that’s not the story we hear. We’re fed tired rhetoric about benefit cheats and welfare dependency while the real theft – wealth siphoned upwards by the richest in society including venal, unregulated corporations – goes unchallenged.
It’s dreadfully dangerous. When people are abandoned by those claiming to represent them, they’ll find someone else to turn to. When the left refuses to articulate clear, radical alternatives to austerity, the populist right steps in with easy answers and convenient scapegoats.
The myth of welfare dependency
People suffering under austerity aren’t fools: they know the system is rigged against them. But if all they see from the left is managerialism, half-measures, and finger-pointing, they’ll look elsewhere. They’ll listen to those who speak ‘plainly’, offering ‘solutions’. Even if those solutions are built on lies, division, and cruelty. History has shown us this time and time again.
Discourse around welfare and austerity is often framed as tensions between economic efficiency and social responsibility, but that’s a false dichotomy. The evidence overwhelmingly shows that strong welfare states lead to better economic outcomes. Countries with robust social safety nets have lower crime rates, better health outcomes, and more stable economies.
The idea that welfare breeds laziness is a myth perpetuated by those who stand to gain from dismantling it. Studies show that increased social spending leads to higher employment rates, not lower. People want to work but need to be given opportunities to do so under fair conditions.
Austerity isn’t a necessity but a choice. It’s a choice to cut benefits rather than raise taxes on the wealthy. A choice to let public services deteriorate rather than invest in them. To demonise the poor – and migration – while turning a blind eye to corporate greed. These choices have left much of Wales, and communities across the UK, struggling to survive, let alone thrive.
It’s time to stop blaming those suffering under austerity and start questioning the people who created it. Because when politicians talk about “difficult decisions” it’s never them or their families making the sacrifices. If the left continues to fail to offer real change they’ll keep losing those who need them most. And to the worst people imaginable.







