• Contact
  • About
DONATE TO BYLINES CYMRU
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
Bylines Cymru
  • Home
  • Politics & Society
    • All
    • Devolution
    • Economy
    • Europe
    • Housing
    • Media
    • Westminster
    A million hours: sand timer on red background

    A million hours to independence

    South Wales industrial landscape, painted by Penry Williams

    Levelling up alone won’t help many of the UK’s ‘left-behind’ places

    YesCymru Abertawe postbox yarn bombing

    YesCymru march for Welsh independence in Swansea

    Newport Train Station, South Wales

    The great Welsh train robbery: why is Welsh rail disconnected?

    Piles of paper

    Civil society speaks out about retained EU law reforms

    Fine lined cartoon of dragon and King Charles facing each other

    The monarchy in an indy Wales

    Pensioner looking at paperwork

    Low-income pensioners in Wales must act urgently or lose out on pension credit

    Tenby, Wales

    Federalism, confederalism, and a model in between

    Charles and Camilla by Plebo

    King Charles’s coronation: what impartial broadcast coverage of the event would look like

    Trending Tags

    • Cost of living
    • Devolution
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Europe
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Media
    • Trade
    • Westminster
  • Arts & Culture
    Bookshop

    National Crime Reading Month: June 2023

    Swansea Bay

    How the Welsh developed their own form of poetry

    Boots on a stage

    Eurovision 2023: why the stage itself is the silent star of the contest

    Microphone

    The rise and fall (and rise again) of linguistic diversity at Eurovision

    Art by David Begley

    Sift: an Ancient Connections exhibition linking Pembrokeshire and Wexford

    Dall-y-Mellt / Rough Cut

    Rough Cut: Netflix’s first Welsh language series

    “Room to Live” exhibition at “NL is US Art”, 2021, Rotterdam, Netherlands © David Powell

    The art of Brexterity: the vandalism of one of the UK’s most profitable sectors

    Watercolour sheep

    Treadle softly: a slowly spinning life

    Nearly empty cinema

    Nepo babies: why nepotism is such a problem for British film and TV – and how to fix it

    Trending Tags

    • Welsh
  • Hiraeth
    Great Plains Welsh Heritage Centre, Wymore, Nebraska

    The Welsh do wander so: a Welsh home on the Plains

    Welsh immigrants in Canada, early 1900s

    The Calgary Welsh Society: a home from home

    Chicago Tafia Welsh Society, Grand Slam, Globe Pub, Chicago, 2008

    Red, white, and green in America

    Conwy, North Wales

    Land of my father

    Jenny Chung, pluviophile, Welsh-Chinese in Hong Kong

    The ghost girl: growing up Welsh-Chinese

    A field of red tulips. Welsh colours in the Netherlands

    Who are we?

    Welsh place names: Yr Wyddfa, Eyryi

    Welsh place names are being erased – and so are the stories they tell

    Trending Tags

    • Voices
      • All
      • Editorial
      • Gwalia | History
      • Opinion
      • Poetry
      Learning Cymraeg

      Embracing y iaith Gymraeg

      Endless growth is impossible. Empty shopping trolley in empty parking arcade

      Everything is shrinking now. Endless growth has ended

      Resilience. Dolgellau, Gwynedd, North Wales

      Welsh Poetry Sunday: Resilience

      Welsh voices by Plebo

      Happy 100: the Bylines Network and citizen journalism

      Rusted steel in India

      Welsh steel workers in colonial India

      An old chair

      Lost then found: the rich history of a kitchen chair

      Photograph of abandoned ice cream van in South Wales by David Collyer

      Welsh poet warns of dystopian future

      Medieval and modern beauty; two eyes

      Medieval beauty ideals were as tough as they are now

      Bus stop at night

      Welsh Poetry Sunday: Huw Evans

      Trending Tags

        • Deialog | Interview
        • Editorial
        • Gwalia | History
        • Opinion
        • Poetry
      • Sports
        Child swimming

        Decreased access to swimming is harming children and young people

        Screenshot from the docuseries Welcome to Wrexham, FX Productions. Season 2 will air sometime later in 2023

        How Wrexham’s football fairy tale is fuelled by Disney and Hollywood glamour

        Cycling Wales

        Cycling Cymru: adventures of an Audaxer

        Mixed martial arts

        Jack ‘The Tank’ Shore and others show how Wales can punch above its weight on the world stage

        April 10th, 2022, Cork, Ireland - Womens Six Nations: Ireland 29 - Italy 8.

        Why are rugby and football fans treated differently?

        Trending Tags

        No Result
        View All Result
        • Home
        • Politics & Society
          • All
          • Devolution
          • Economy
          • Europe
          • Housing
          • Media
          • Westminster
          A million hours: sand timer on red background

          A million hours to independence

          South Wales industrial landscape, painted by Penry Williams

          Levelling up alone won’t help many of the UK’s ‘left-behind’ places

          YesCymru Abertawe postbox yarn bombing

          YesCymru march for Welsh independence in Swansea

          Newport Train Station, South Wales

          The great Welsh train robbery: why is Welsh rail disconnected?

          Piles of paper

          Civil society speaks out about retained EU law reforms

          Fine lined cartoon of dragon and King Charles facing each other

          The monarchy in an indy Wales

          Pensioner looking at paperwork

          Low-income pensioners in Wales must act urgently or lose out on pension credit

          Tenby, Wales

          Federalism, confederalism, and a model in between

          Charles and Camilla by Plebo

          King Charles’s coronation: what impartial broadcast coverage of the event would look like

          Trending Tags

          • Cost of living
          • Devolution
          • Economy
          • Education
          • Europe
          • Health
          • Housing
          • Media
          • Trade
          • Westminster
        • Arts & Culture
          Bookshop

          National Crime Reading Month: June 2023

          Swansea Bay

          How the Welsh developed their own form of poetry

          Boots on a stage

          Eurovision 2023: why the stage itself is the silent star of the contest

          Microphone

          The rise and fall (and rise again) of linguistic diversity at Eurovision

          Art by David Begley

          Sift: an Ancient Connections exhibition linking Pembrokeshire and Wexford

          Dall-y-Mellt / Rough Cut

          Rough Cut: Netflix’s first Welsh language series

          “Room to Live” exhibition at “NL is US Art”, 2021, Rotterdam, Netherlands © David Powell

          The art of Brexterity: the vandalism of one of the UK’s most profitable sectors

          Watercolour sheep

          Treadle softly: a slowly spinning life

          Nearly empty cinema

          Nepo babies: why nepotism is such a problem for British film and TV – and how to fix it

          Trending Tags

          • Welsh
        • Hiraeth
          Great Plains Welsh Heritage Centre, Wymore, Nebraska

          The Welsh do wander so: a Welsh home on the Plains

          Welsh immigrants in Canada, early 1900s

          The Calgary Welsh Society: a home from home

          Chicago Tafia Welsh Society, Grand Slam, Globe Pub, Chicago, 2008

          Red, white, and green in America

          Conwy, North Wales

          Land of my father

          Jenny Chung, pluviophile, Welsh-Chinese in Hong Kong

          The ghost girl: growing up Welsh-Chinese

          A field of red tulips. Welsh colours in the Netherlands

          Who are we?

          Welsh place names: Yr Wyddfa, Eyryi

          Welsh place names are being erased – and so are the stories they tell

          Trending Tags

          • Voices
            • All
            • Editorial
            • Gwalia | History
            • Opinion
            • Poetry
            Learning Cymraeg

            Embracing y iaith Gymraeg

            Endless growth is impossible. Empty shopping trolley in empty parking arcade

            Everything is shrinking now. Endless growth has ended

            Resilience. Dolgellau, Gwynedd, North Wales

            Welsh Poetry Sunday: Resilience

            Welsh voices by Plebo

            Happy 100: the Bylines Network and citizen journalism

            Rusted steel in India

            Welsh steel workers in colonial India

            An old chair

            Lost then found: the rich history of a kitchen chair

            Photograph of abandoned ice cream van in South Wales by David Collyer

            Welsh poet warns of dystopian future

            Medieval and modern beauty; two eyes

            Medieval beauty ideals were as tough as they are now

            Bus stop at night

            Welsh Poetry Sunday: Huw Evans

            Trending Tags

              • Deialog | Interview
              • Editorial
              • Gwalia | History
              • Opinion
              • Poetry
            • Sports
              Child swimming

              Decreased access to swimming is harming children and young people

              Screenshot from the docuseries Welcome to Wrexham, FX Productions. Season 2 will air sometime later in 2023

              How Wrexham’s football fairy tale is fuelled by Disney and Hollywood glamour

              Cycling Wales

              Cycling Cymru: adventures of an Audaxer

              Mixed martial arts

              Jack ‘The Tank’ Shore and others show how Wales can punch above its weight on the world stage

              April 10th, 2022, Cork, Ireland - Womens Six Nations: Ireland 29 - Italy 8.

              Why are rugby and football fans treated differently?

              Trending Tags

              No Result
              View All Result
              Bylines Cymru
              No Result
              View All Result
              Home Politics & Society Europe

              Brexit isn’t working

              Forget what you have heard: freedom of movement after Brexit and rejoining the single market are potential vote winners.

              Paul WillnerRichard BentallbyPaul WillnerandRichard Bentall
              01-03-2023 06:01
              in Europe, Politics & Society
              Leaky Brexit mug, Bentham Pottery

              Leaky Brexit mug. Photo by and with permission of Lee Cartledge and Bentham Pottery

              Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

              It is increasingly apparent even to the right-wing press that Brexit isn’t working. It is difficult to see how Labour’s mission to “make Brexit work” could provide more than a very partial solution to the problems created by the Conservative government’s implementation of a hard Brexit. But recent data show that, contrary to received wisdom, a policy of reinstating freedom of movement and rejoining the EU single market could pay dividends.

              Brexit is damaging

              Brexit has inflicted serious damage on the UK economy. A recent (June 2022) report from the Centre for European Reform has estimated that UK GDP is 5.2% smaller than it would otherwise have been, investment is 13.7% lower, and goods trade 13.6% lower. The LSE Centre for Economic Performance estimated in 2020 that the eventual cost of Brexit to the UK economy is likely to be more than double that of the Covid pandemic, a view shared by the chair of the Office for Budgetary Responsibility.

              The Resolution Foundation has estimated that Brexit will cost each UK worker £470 every year over the coming decade. And the Office for National Statistics has reported the worst balance of trade figures since records began.

              This is before taking into account the cost of living crisis and the destructive effects on the UK economy of policies advanced by the Truss and Sunak governments. And without including full implementation of the trade and cooperation agreement, which the minister for Brexit opportunities said would be an act of national self-harm.

              The impact of Brexit is felt particularly severely in Wales, which prior to Brexit exported more to the EU (61%) than did the rest of the UK (48%). As a consequence, the Welsh Centre for Public Policy has estimated a £1.1bn hit to Welsh exports, with a particular impact on machinery exports owing to ‘rules of origin’ requirements, and a 30% decrease in traffic through the Welsh ports of Fishguard and Holyhead.

              Small businesses in sectors such as agriculture and tourism have been hit by the failure of the UK Government to honour its promise to match the loss of EU funding, at a cost estimated by the Welsh Government to amount to a further £1.1bn. As recently as September 2019, the Welsh Government argued strongly that the UK should remain within the EU, in order to safeguard not only the economy, but also social and environmental protections and the devolution settlement, all of which are at now at risk.

              The damage caused by Brexit is widely recognised: opinion polls on the question of whether Brexit is going well or badly have shown a steady deterioration in public support, with well over three times as many now thinking that Brexit is going badly than think it is going well (54% to 16%). There is now a consistent majority (around 55% of those expressing a view) saying that Brexit was a mistake. The veteran pollster Peter Kellner has concluded that: “Given how slowly public opinion has changed, this looks like a verdict that is as settled as anything ever is in politics. Britain is no longer a pro-Brexit country.”

              Can Brexit be made to work?

              The failure of Brexit is particularly salient to Labour supporters, over 80% of whom think Brexit is going badly compared to only 3% who see it as succeeding. In response, the Labour Party has adopted a policy of “making Brexit work”. Can this be done?

              Certainly, there are some steps that that could be taken to improve the situation. But in setting out his proposals, summarized in Table 1, Keir Starmer acknowledged that “outside of the Single Market and a Customs Union we will not be able to deliver complete frictionless trade with the EU”.

              After a Labour government has implemented these changes, there will still be long queues at the border and a massive hit to the economy and family budgets. There will also remain costs and lost opportunities for UK citizens, such as the 90-day limit on Schengen visits, separation of families, means tests, and visa and roaming charges, to name but a few. The only way to close these gaps outside the Single Market and Customs Union would be to create a multitude of separate treaty arrangements, comparable to those negotiated by Switzerland, which the EU have stated unequivocally would not be acceptable.

              Labour PartyEuropean Movement
              a new veterinary agreement for agri-product tradenegotiate common veterinary arrangements
              a system for low-risk goods to enter Northern Ireland without checkssort out trade with Northern Ireland
              “flexible labour mobility arrangements” for people making short-term business trips between the UK and EU, and for musicians and artists embarking on toursvisas for lorry drivers and other essential workers
              mutual recognition of professional qualifications with the EU and a new policing and security arrangement with Brusselsre-join the Erasmus study programme for universities
              Table 1: Policies proposed to ameliorate Brexit damage

              Alongside the Labour proposals, Table 1 also lists very similar proposals from the European Movement. But after plucking these low-hanging fruit, the two sets of proposals diverge. The European Movement plans represent only a first step, to be followed by rejoining the EU Single Market and Customs Union. But Labour has ruled out Single Market and Customs Union membership. Why?

              A striking feature of the reluctance of the Labour Party to campaign for single market membership is the conspicuous absence of a plausible explanation as to why such a simple and powerful solution is being rejected. But a reason is apparent from a steady stream of rhetoric over the past six years that has coalesced into a settled dogma: single market membership would mean the return of freedom of movement which, it is believed, would so anger leave voters that they would withdraw support from a party advocating it. But new data show that this assumption is incorrect.

              Freedom of movement is NOT toxic to leavers

              We conducted a large (>2K), nationally representative survey, asking participants how acceptable they would find five scenarios for the future of the Brexit process. Participants were identified as leavers, remainers, or neither from their responses to a short questionnaire, with three leave-supporting and three remain-supporting items (e.g. ‘I identify strongly with people who voted to leave/remain in the European Union’).

              Alongside hard Brexit and second referendum options, we included three visions of ‘A new deal with Europe’, involving either free trade, freedom of movement, or both. Each scenario was presented with a detailed explanation, and a rationale. In Figure 1, the acceptability of each scenario is broken down according to participants’ Brexit identities. Unsurprisingly, the hard Brexit option (‘An Independent Sovereign UK’) was unacceptable to remainers (Figure 1A), while the idea of a second referendum (‘Rethink Brexit’) was unacceptable to leavers (Figure 1B).

              However, the three ‘new deal’ options were all similarly attractive to leavers as to remainers (Figure 1 C,D,E). For both groups, each of free trade, freedom of movement, and the combination of both elements was acceptable to more than 50% of participants and unacceptable to less than 20%. Participants who did not express a Brexit identity also reported very low (10%) levels of unacceptability for all of the ‘new deal’ options.

              Graph showing acceptability of five hypothetical UK-EU futures to participants identifying as remainers or leavers, as described in the text
              Figure 1 Acceptability (%) of five hypothetical UK-EU futures to participants identifying as remainers or leavers

              These data suggest strongly that the conventional wisdom is mistaken. When the meaning is spelled out, freedom of movement is not toxic to leavers, who are almost as positive about it as remainers. Moreover, almost identical levels of support were found for the third ‘new deal’ option which envisages both free trade and freedom of movement – a close approximation to single market membership.

              Freedom of movement and single market membership could be vote winners

              Opposition to freedom of movement and single market membership are policies that risk alienating millions of remainers and appear to be equally unpopular with leavers. Reviewing recent polling data, Peter Kellner points out that Labour polls at its worst, at 14% (well below the Conservatives), on “Which party would handle Brexit best?”, and argues that “Labour’s ultra-cautious stance on the EU isn’t working … Labour has irritated many pro-Europeans while failing to persuade more than a small minority of pro-Brexit voters that it knows the right way forward. … If Brexit (starts) to matter as the campaign unfolds, then Labour’s manifest weakness on the subject might cost it dearly.”

              The LibDems have agreed on a roadmap to rejoining the single market, a policy that is also supported by Plaid Cymru. But Keir Starmer stated in his ‘make Brexit work’ speech that a Labour government would not seek to reintroduce freedom of movement or rejoin the single market because this would not “help stimulate growth or bring down food prices or help British business thrive in the modern world”.

              Since single market membership would almost certainly stimulate growth, reduce food prices, and reinvigorate British business, these are questionable grounds to rule out policies that – according to our data – could command wide support across the Brexit divide.

                  Enjoyed that? Why not buy us a coffee?
              Tags: BrexitCost of livingexportsfreedom of movementsingle market
              Previous Post

              Welsh place names are being erased – and so are the stories they tell

              Next Post

              Who are we?

              Paul Willner

              Paul Willner

              Paul Willner is emeritus professor of psychology at Swansea University. He founded Swansea for Europe and chaired the group until 2020. He is now a board member of Wales for Europe and is a member of various pro-European groups within the Labour Party.

              Richard Bentall

              Richard Bentall

              Richard Bentall is a professor of clinical psychology at the University of Sheffield. His work mostly focuses on severe mental illness and the mechanisms leading to symptoms such as hallucinations and delusions, the effectiveness of psychological treatments for people who are affected by them, and the social determinants of mental illness. Recently, he has also been conducting research on the psychology of political beliefs. He has written several books, most notably Madness Explained (Penguin, 2003).

              Related Posts

              A million hours: sand timer on red background
              Politics & Society

              A million hours to independence

              byGeraint Thomas
              8 June 2023
              South Wales industrial landscape, painted by Penry Williams
              Politics & Society

              Levelling up alone won’t help many of the UK’s ‘left-behind’ places

              byRobert Huggins
              1 June 2023
              YesCymru Abertawe postbox yarn bombing
              Politics & Society

              YesCymru march for Welsh independence in Swansea

              byYesCymru
              20 May 2023
              Newport Train Station, South Wales
              Politics & Society

              The great Welsh train robbery: why is Welsh rail disconnected?

              byTrystan Gruffydd
              20 May 2023 - Updated on 30 May 2023
              Piles of paper
              Politics & Society

              Civil society speaks out about retained EU law reforms

              byCivil Society Alliance
              17 May 2023
              Next Post
              A field of red tulips. Welsh colours in the Netherlands

              Who are we?

              PLEASE SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

              Subscribe to our newsletters
              CHOOSE YOUR NEWS
              Follow us on social media
              CHOOSE YOUR PLATFORMS
              Download our app
              ALL OF BYLINES IN ONE PLACE
              Subscribe to our gazette
              CONTRIBUTE TO OUR SUSTAINABILITY
              Make a monthly or one-off donation
              DONATE NOW
              Help us with our hosting costs
              SIGN UP TO SITEGROUND
              We are always looking for citizen journalists
              WRITE FOR US
              Volunteer as an editor, in a technical role, or on social media
              VOLUNTEER FOR US
              Something else?
              GET IN TOUCH
              Previous slide
              Next slide

              LATEST

              A million hours: sand timer on red background

              A million hours to independence

              8 June 2023
              Learning Cymraeg

              Embracing y iaith Gymraeg

              6 June 2023
              Endless growth is impossible. Empty shopping trolley in empty parking arcade

              Everything is shrinking now. Endless growth has ended

              5 June 2023
              Climate change cartoon by Dawn Mockler

              Britain’s wild woods are under threat and we’re running out of time to save them

              5 June 2023

              MOST READ

              A million hours: sand timer on red background

              A million hours to independence

              8 June 2023
              Learning Cymraeg

              Embracing y iaith Gymraeg

              6 June 2023
              Riding a bus

              On the number 65: the best bus route in Wales?

              24 May 2023 - Updated on 8 June 2023
              Endless growth is impossible. Empty shopping trolley in empty parking arcade

              Everything is shrinking now. Endless growth has ended

              5 June 2023

              BROWSE BY TAGS

              accountability Brexit campaign citizen journalism climate change community Cost of living creativity Cymraeg democracy devolution economy education environment EU Europe Football freeports habitat history identity inclusion independence industry journalism Language literature mental health monarchy nature place names poetry politics regulation research South Wales sustainability taxation trade Welsh Welsh history Welshness Welsh poetry Westminster YesCymru
              Bylines Cymru

              We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Cymru and beyond.

              Bylines Cymru is a trading brand of Bylines Network Limited, which is a partner organisation to Byline Times.

              Learn more about us

              No Result
              View All Result
              • About
              • Authors
              • Network
              • Contact
              • Donate
              • Privacy

              © 2023 Bylines Cymru. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Home
              • Politics & Society
                • Devolution
                • Economy
                • Education
                • Health
                • Housing
                • Media
                • Trade
                • Westminster
              • Arts & Culture
              • Hiraeth
              • Voices | Lleisiau
                • Deialog | Interview
                • Editorial
                • Gwalia | History
                • Opinion
                • Poetry
              • Sports & Leisure
              • Newsletter sign up
              • Authors
              CROWDFUNDER

              © 2023 Bylines Cymru. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              Welcome Back!

              Login to your account below

              Forgotten Password?

              Retrieve your password

              Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

              Log In