People from England are “hopping the border” to “take advantage” of more generous allowances on care home fees, a Welsh council boss has said. The finance officer for social care in Monmouthshire said that has meant the border county having to pick up the cost of people coming to Wales to avoid care home charges. It contributed to a predicted £3mn overspend in its adult services budget.
Tyrone Stokes, the county council’s finance manager for social care and health, dubbed the issue “social tourism”. He was outlining cost pressures faced by the council during this financial year to a scrutiny committee when he said there are some care costs it has an obligation to meet.
Social tourism
Stokes told councillors: “In terms of the statistics in Monmouthshire we have still got an aging demographic population, the same across the country. But in Monmouthshire we are quite attractive to people retiring, bringing in older people to the county. And we also do suffer from, and I use the term loosely so please forgive me, suffer somewhat from ‘social tourism’.”
“Monmouthshire is an affluent borough bordering a number of English counties, and the charging regime in Wales is much more generous than in England. So we do see people hopping over the border to try and take advantage of that. We do suffer a lot more than any other Welsh border authority because somebody in England could be closer to a care home, or care facility, in Wales than they are in their own English borough, if that makes sense.”
People going into residential care in Wales have their fees fully funded if they have assets of less than £50,000, while the figure in England is £14,250. The council has confirmed that people from England can be eligible for help from it in meeting their care costs.
Increased demand in Monmouthshire
The committee was also told that, from the start of the current financial year last April, the number of people whose care the council funds at homes – other than at the Severn View home in Chepstow, which it runs – had increased by 10% to 294 by September. That meant it was paying for care for an additional 26 people, above the 268 places it was funding at the start of the year, contributing to a further £1.25mn in costs.
Mr Stokes said that to keep control of costs the council now has a quality assurance panel to consider every care package. It looks at issues such as whether reablement can be provided, and the most appropriate care setting. A report for the committee said a “gatekeeping panel” looks at all requests for “high-cost care packages including residential placements”. It said part of the continued rise in residential placements is due to them being used when the cost of care at home is more than a residential placement costs.
Monmouthshire Council confirmed that people moving into care homes in Monmouthshire from England can potentially be eligible for local authority financial assistance. This depends on a means-tested financial assessment in line with the Social Services and Wellbeing Act (Wales) 2014.
An underlying overspend
A council spokesperson said: “Before making any funding decisions, we consider all our options, including establishing where ordinary residence should be, as this establishes which local authority should be responsible.” They added that “many factors” are taken into account when considering a care home placement, including location to the client and their family connections, suitability, and availability.
The committee report said underspends in the adult social care budget – including £1.1mn from a social care workforce grant, £900,000 related to the My Day, My Life support service for adults with learning disabilities, and care at home vacancies – had helped to ease the budget pressures. But this masked the “true underlying overspend, more in the region of £5mn”.
At a separate scrutiny committee, it was confirmed that, when the most recent monthly invoices for care were issued by the council, it invoiced 735 clients for care including at home, respite, and day care. In addition, 165 care packages were assessed as free of any charge.






