The latest episode in the patently never-ending saga of Donald Trump’s battles with the so-called legacy media began this month when the US president announced his decision to sue the Rupert Murdoch-owned Wall Street Journal. Trump is alleging libel and slander, describing the newspaper of reporting a story which he claims is “false, malicious, and defamatory”.
Trump’s anger is over an article published on 17 July 2025 which stated that Trump had sent a vulgar birthday greeting letter to billionaire Jeffery Epstein in 2003, some years before Epstein was convicted of major sex crimes. The letter was part of a ‘birthday book’ presented to Epstein and had a crude drawing of a female nude and ended with the message: “A pal is a wonderful thing. Happy Birthday – and may every day be another wonderful secret.”
About the case, worth over $10bn, Trump wrote on his Truth Social site: “We have just filed a POWERHOUSE Lawsuit against everyone involved in publishing the false, malicious, defamatory, FAKE NEWS ‘article’ in the useless ‘rag’ that is, The Wall Street Journal.”
Trump wages war on freedom of the press
Such disparaging remarks have become a feature of Trump’s relationship with the mainstream media since the beginning of his first term as president in 2016. Indeed, in 2020, the Committee to Protect Journalists published an investigation which stated that he was effectively trying to “destroy the credibility of the press”.
But as his second term gathers momentum it is has become clear that the Trump campaign has moved beyond abusive terminology and rhetoric. As Paul Farhi wrote in the Atlantic on 21 July, Trump is now waging a “multifront war on media freedom with all of the tools at his disposal: executive actions, lawsuits, a loyal regulatory bureaucracy, a compliant Republican majority in Congress and a sympathetic Supreme Court. Each of his actions has been extraordinary in its own right; collectively, they represent a slow-motion demolition of the Fourth Estate”.
Just a cursory glance at what has happened in the past year indicates the potency of this view. In December 2024, ABC News agreed to pay $15mn in a defamation suit where a presenter had said that Trump had been “liable for rape”. Many noted media analysts, including CNN’s Brian Stelter, thought that ABC (and parent company Disney) were far too swift in settling the case, intimating that they were cowed by the reputational and business damage a protracted wrangle with the president of the US could engender.
The price of speaking truth to power
But Stelter might care to now examine his own employers. Paramount, CBS News’s parent company, settled a $16mn lawsuit this summer which claimed it deceptively edited an interview with the then vice president Kamala Harris to make her appear more sympathetic. The Federal Communications Commission has stated that the Harris incident could significantly harm Paramount’s proposed $8bn merger with Skydance Media.
So, with these legal measures and the now usual attacks on the conventional media as “enemies of the people”, Trump is marginalising the traditional mouthpieces of America whilst elevating the pro-MAGA bloggers and sympathisers. In light of the lawsuit against the newspaper, the White House has barred the Wall Street Journal from the travelling press party which will accompany the president on his trip to Scotland from 25 to 29 July. Karoline Leavitt, Trump’s press secretary, stated on Monday: “Thirteen diverse outlets will participate in the press pool to cover the president’s trip to Scotland. Due to The Wall Street Journal’s fake and defamatory conduct, they will not be one of the 13 outlets on board.”
But in taking on the Murdoch-owned newspaper, has Trump met his match? The Wall Street Journal has declared its willingness to defend itself against Trump’s lawsuit, issuing a statement which said: “We have full confidence in the rigour and accuracy of our reporting, and will vigorously defend against any lawsuit.”
Murdoch’s power over politicians
And the Murdoch/Trump relationship is not as close as some imagine. Theirs has been a marriage of convenience built on mutual necessity and there is no love lost between the pair. Michael Wolff, a biographer of both men, has stated that Murdoch detests Trump and thinks he’s a moron and alleged that Murdoch literally wishes Trump dead.
Murdoch has a rich history of ending political relationships if they no longer benefit him or his businesses. In Australia in the 1970s, when Labour’s Gough Whitlam was forced to leave office, it was in part because of the role played by the Murdoch press. In The Australian newspaper, Whitlam’s government was linked with financial and sexual impropriety. Indeed, Murdoch himself wrote some of the stories as he sought to end his relationship with a politician who had ceased to be of any value.
In the UK in 1997, former Prime Minister John Major told the Leveson inquiry into the standards and ethics of the press that Murdoch said he could not guarantee continued media support. He said: “Mr Murdoch said he really didn’t like our European policies. He wished me to change our European policies. If we couldn’t change our European policies his papers could not, would not support our Conservative Government.” Very soon after this, the media magnate’s empire came out in support of Tony Blair’s Labour Party.
MAGA dichotomy: fight against “gutter press” or fight for release of Epstein files?
Murdoch, in the twilight of his life, might be emboldened enough to fight Trump and face down the threats. The legendary Tina Brown, journalist and former “queen of the glossies”, has said that she doesn’t expect Murdoch to capitulate under pressure. He is, she posits, a popular journalist above all else and “won’t pay Trump a dime for the Epstein story. Even at a grumpy 94, Murdoch is still a tabloid man to his core”.
But there is another way in which all this might play out. The MAGA base has been calling for the release of the Epstein files: MAGA has been suspicious of Epstein’s involvement in a shadowy system controlling government. As I write, it appears that the base has now closed ranks behind Trump in what it sees as a continuation of the fight against the corrupt gutter press intent on overthrowing their leader.
Jack Posobeic, a right-wing cheerleader and broadcaster, stated: “We’re so back. Everyone is firing on all cylinders. The MAGA movement is completely united behind this fight.”







