Welsh Labour wants May’s Senedd election to be fought on devolved delivery, not the UK government’s reputation. That plea is understandable; it is also a warning sign. Under the new voting system, party brands will be harder to escape, and voters will judge the whole chain of responsibility, from Cardiff Bay to Westminster.
When a governing party has to say, out loud, “do not treat this election as a referendum on our leader”, it is rarely because everything is going smoothly.
That is the political meaning behind First Minister Eluned Morgan’s insistence that the Senedd election should not become a referendum on Keir Starmer. The civic argument is respectable: the Senedd election should be about Wales, and about what the Welsh Government has done with the powers it holds. But the subtext is clear enough. Welsh Labour believes the UK brand is weighing it down; it wants a firewall.
A firewall is only built when there is smoke
In normal times, devolved incumbents plead for credit on local delivery and ask voters to judge them on their own record. In difficult times, they also ask voters to ignore the national weather.
Morgan’s message is an attempt to separate devolved accountability from UK-level brand drag. It is also, by definition, an admission that the separation is not holding. Voters do not experience government as neatly divided into two tiers. They experience outcomes such as waiting times, transport reliability, council tax, housing costs, energy bills, and job security. Some of this is devolved; a great deal is constrained by decisions taken elsewhere, and the interaction is constant.
That is why the “make it about Wales” plea feels simultaneously fair and politically self-serving. It is fair because Welsh debates are too often flattened into Westminster proxy wars. It is self-serving because Welsh Labour is asking the electorate to treat the party as distinct only when the UK party is unpopular.
The 2026 system makes brand separation harder, not easier
This election is not taking place under familiar rules. On 7 May 2026, Wales votes in a new system: the Senedd expands to 96 members, voters have one vote, and Wales is divided into 16 constituencies, each electing six members. Candidates must also live in Wales.
Whatever one thinks of the reform, it has an obvious political implication. The ballot is more explicitly party-centred than many voters are used to. When the choice is a party list (or an independent list), it is harder for any party to argue: “forget the national label; focus on the local brand.”
That matters because Welsh Labour’s pitch depends on persuading voters to treat “Labour in Wales” as something meaningfully insulated from “Labour in the UK”. The mechanics of the election push in the other direction: they focus attention on party identity and party competence.
Devolution’s built-in accountability tangle
There is a recurring pattern in devolved politics. Devolved governments can be punished for outcomes shaped by reserved powers; UK governments can evade blame for outcomes mediated through devolved delivery. The result is a constant, frustrating muddle in public understanding, and a constant temptation for parties to narrate events in whichever direction helps them.
Welsh Labour’s “not a referendum” line is an attempt to tidy up the muddle, but only on one side. It wants voters to attribute Cardiff Bay’s successes to Welsh Labour’s competence and Cardiff Bay’s constraints to Westminster’s decisions. It is a perfectly rational political strategy; it is not a recipe for clearer accountability.
The recent Welsh budget episode is a good example of the real-world entanglement. Welsh Labour passed the 2026–27 budget after securing a deal with Plaid Cymru, which agreed to abstain. The budget itself may be defended or criticised on its merits. Still, it illustrates the deeper point: devolved governance is constrained by funding settlements, macroeconomic conditions, and UK-level choices that Welsh ministers do not control. Wales cannot be governed as though Westminster is irrelevant, even when politicians would like a cleaner argument on the doorstep.
The deeper discomfort: credit without responsibility
Welsh Labour cannot, over time, have it both ways. It cannot claim the credibility that comes with being the party of government across Britain, then plead that voters treat the UK government as unrelated when that government is politically toxic.
The Morgan line also reveals a broader discomfort with accountability within parties. If you want voters to judge devolved performance, you have to accept that they will also judge how your party behaves in Westminster, and whether your Welsh leadership looks willing to challenge its own side when Welsh interests diverge. When that challenge is absent, “make it about Wales” starts to sound less like a democratic principle and more like message discipline.
What a genuinely Wales-focused contest would look like
If Welsh Labour truly wants a Wales election, it should welcome Wales-level scrutiny that is specific and measurable.
That would mean, at minimum:
- Concrete delivery targets for health, schools, transport and local government, and a willingness to be judged against them.
- Honesty about constraint: what is devolved, what is reserved, and which failures are genuinely structural rather than convenient excuses.
- Clarity about governing relationships, because the next Senedd is likely to normalise bargaining and co-operation, not single-party dominance.
The same standard applies to the opposition parties. It is easy to ride anger, particularly in a moment of national discontent. It is harder to explain what you would do with devolved levers, what you would prioritise first, what you would cut or delay, and what coalitions you would consider acceptable to implement any of it.
The bottom line
Morgan is right that Wales deserves a Welsh election. She is also signalling that Welsh Labour fears it is heading into one with an anchor tied to its ankle.
The question is not whether May becomes a referendum on Starmer in the narrow, sloganistic sense. The question is whether Welsh politics can grow up into a culture of joined-up accountability: one where voters judge parties in full, across Cardiff Bay and Westminster, and where parties stop pretending the two worlds float in separate orbits.

Bylines Network Gazette is out!
The latest Bylines Network Gazette is out now. Become a Friend of Bylines Network or upgrade to a paid Substack subscription, and you will get access to a vital collection of citizen articles and stories.
Journalism by the people, for the people.







