• Contact
  • About
  • ISSN 3049-9712
  • Authors and editors
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
Bylines Cymru
Advertisement
  • Home
  • Politics & Society
    • Devolution
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Europe
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Media
    • Trade
    • Westminster
  • Arts & Culture
  • Hiraeth
  • Voices
    • Deialog | Interview
    • Editorial
    • Gwalia | History
    • Opinion
    • Poetry
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics & Society
    • Devolution
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Europe
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Media
    • Trade
    • Westminster
  • Arts & Culture
  • Hiraeth
  • Voices
    • Deialog | Interview
    • Editorial
    • Gwalia | History
    • Opinion
    • Poetry
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
Bylines Cymru
Home Voices | Lleisiau Opinion

Senedd elections: proportional, but not democratic enough

Wales is moving to PR, but closed lists weaken voter power – open-list PR would put accountability and choice back in voters’ hands

Jack Meredith by Jack Meredith
04-02-2026 17:20
in Opinion, Politics & Society
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
Pierhead Street, Cardiff , Wales , UK 27 Oct 2024 : The Senedd which is Welsh Parliament in Cardiff Bay

image by Steve Travelguide. Licensed by Shutterstock [SD]

Share on Bluesky

Next year, the Senedd will take an historic step forward. For the first time, Wales will elect all of its members of the Senedd (MSs) through a fully proportional system.

For too long, Welsh elections have used a mixed-member voting system that has seen votes wasted, smaller parties squeezed, and many voices under-represented. But while the destination is welcome, the route being taken is not the best one.

Wales is moving to a closed-list proportional representation system, a model that improves fairness between parties but reduces fairness between voters and the individuals who represent them in the Senedd. If we genuinely believe in liberal democracy, accountability and putting power in the hands of citizens, then Wales must go further. Open-list PR would give voters the voice they deserve.

Where we’re coming from: MMPR

Since the Senedd’s creation, Wales has elected its representatives through a form of mixed-member proportional representation (MMPR). This gave voters two choices: a local constituency MS (elected by first-past-the-post (FPTP)), and a regional party list.

Without a doubt, there were clear strengths with MMPR. Voters had a constituency link, knowing who their local MS was, and it gave them a sense of relatability, while also providing an element of proportionality, ensuring that votes for smaller parties were not entirely wasted.

The weakness of this system, however, was apparent. FPTP skewed representation, often benefiting bigger parties and leaving many voters feeling that their vote didn’t matter, while also shackling smaller parties’ potential to break through.

So it is clear that reform was overdue. But the replacement is far from perfect.

Where we’re going: closed-list PR

The new voting system will divide Wales into sixteen large constituencies, each electing six MSs. Voters will cast a single vote for a party, with seats then distributed proportionally.

The candidates and their order are set entirely by the party leadership. This means if a party wins three seats in an area, the top three names on its pre-determined list are elected. Voters cannot move candidates up or down the list; their only choice is the party label.

This raises serious risks:

  • Power is centralised in party headquarters, who decide the order of the list.
  • Voter influence is weakened, as individuals no longer have a say in who represents their area.
  • Accountability is lost, as MSs may end up answering more to the party that decides their list placement than to their constituents.
  • Local connections are weakened, as each constituency now covers six seats and voters cannot distinguish between candidates within a party.

Closed-list PR is certainly more proportional than MMPR, but it does not deliver the kind of democratic accountability the Senedd should aspire to.

An illustration of a political lier with a long lying nose as corruption and dishonesty metaphor. Corrupt politics concept
Politics & Society

One country is trying to outlaw political lying, without curbing free speech

by Stephen Clear
30 January 2026 - Updated on 16 February 2026

Why open-list PR would be better

Open-list PR offers a better balance. Under this model, voters still cast their vote for a party, ensuring proportional outcomes. But they can also express a preference for individual candidates on the party list.

The more preference votes a candidate receives, the higher they move up the list, making them more likely to be elected.

The benefits for Wales are clear:

  • Stronger accountability, as MSs cannot rely solely on party favour and must answer directly to voters.
  • A closer connection to communities, fostering a stronger local voice in the Senedd.
  • Greater voter choice, allowing people to distinguish between different voices within a party.
  • A system that aligns with Wales’s political culture, where voters often feel a strong personal link to their representatives.

Open democracy, not closed doors

We cannot, and should not, downplay the fact that a move to proportional representation is a huge step forward for Wales. But closed-list PR should not be where we stop.

If the Senedd is to reflect not just how people vote, but also who people want representing them, then open-list PR is the next logical step. It delivers a Welsh democracy that is fairer and freer.

In the end, closed lists mean closed doors. Open lists mean open democracy. If we are serious about giving power to the people, then the choice is clear.


Bylines Network Gazette is out!

The latest Bylines Network Gazette is out now. Become a Friend of Bylines Network or upgrade to a paid Substack subscription, and you will get access to a vital collection of citizen articles and stories.

Journalism by the people, for the people.

Previous Post

Rhondda council to spend millions protecting residents from rising flood risks

Next Post

Forever chemicals, forever waiting? UK’s PFAS plan under fire

Jack Meredith

Jack Meredith

Jack Meredith is a Wales-based writer and political analyst focused on democracy, institutions, and liberal social democracy. His work examines how decisions are made, challenged, and legitimised, and how political trust is shaped by accountability, organisation, and reform. He writes on Welsh and UK politics, with a particular interest in devolution, public services, and the health of democratic institutions. Jack is the Wales Chair for Centre Think Tank. Follow Jack on Bluesky and Substack.

Related Posts

President Harry S. Truman meets with Illinois Governor Adlai Stevenson and Alabama Senator John Sparkman in the Oval Office. Stevenson and Sparkman had just accepted the Democratic nominations for President and Vice President, respectively.
History

How would Trump’s pursuit of a third term unfold?

by Samuel James Jackson
12 November 2026
Sunset sky clouds evening yellow orange.
Community | Cymuned

Building a stronger future for citizen journalism in Wales and beyond

by Robert G Davies
11 November 2026
Image depicting cooperation between Great Britain and the EU
Business

Will the new UK–EU food deal deliver for Welsh farmers?

by Gareth Wyn Roberts
10 November 2026
White concrete building with red and yellow flag on top under blue sky.during-daytime
Politics & Society

Spanish elections: a cultural view from the País Valencià, and parallels with Wales

by Joan Pedro-Carañana, Enrique Uribe Jongbloed and Toby Miller
9 November 2026
A garden filled with lots of different types of flowers.
Environment

A love lesson from the garden

by Martha Garcia
6 November 2026
Next Post
Red PFAS ( Forever Chemicals ) stamp with a river in the background -- water contamination concept

Forever chemicals, forever waiting? UK’s PFAS plan under fire

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

BROWSE BY TAGS

austerity Austerity Project Brexit campaign climate change community Cost of living Covid Cymraeg democracy devolution economy education energy environment equality events general election health history identity inclusion independence international journalism mental health older people opinion party politics Plaid Cymru Poetry Sunday politics public health public services research Senedd South Wales Welsh culture Welsh Government Welsh heritage Welsh history Welsh language Welsh poetry Welsh writers Westminster
Bylines Cymru

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Cymru and beyond.

Bylines Cymru is a trading brand of Bylines Networks Limited which is separate to, but allied with, Byline Times.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Authors and editors
  • Complaints
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Privacy
  • Network Map
  • Network RSS Feeds
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Download the Bylines Network App

© 2023-2026 Bylines Cymru. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9712

No Result
View All Result
  • Politics & Society
    • Devolution
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Media
    • Trade
    • Westminster
  • Arts & Culture
  • Hiraeth
  • Voices | Lleisiau
    • Deialog | Interview
    • Editorial
    • Gwalia | History
    • Opinion
    • Poetry
  • Sports & Leisure

Newsletter sign up

CROWDFUNDER

© 2023-2026 Bylines Cymru. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9712