• Contact
  • About
  • ISSN 3049-9712
  • Authors and editors
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
Bylines Cymru
Advertisement
  • Home
  • Politics & Society
    • Devolution
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Europe
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Media
    • Trade
    • Westminster
  • Arts & Culture
  • Hiraeth
  • Voices
    • Deialog | Interview
    • Editorial
    • Gwalia | History
    • Opinion
    • Poetry
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics & Society
    • Devolution
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Europe
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Media
    • Trade
    • Westminster
  • Arts & Culture
  • Hiraeth
  • Voices
    • Deialog | Interview
    • Editorial
    • Gwalia | History
    • Opinion
    • Poetry
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
Bylines Cymru
Home Politics & Society

The economic basis for Welsh independence: part two

The data relevant to whether Welsh independence is economically viable was at first sparse, then available but flawed, but is growing increasingly sophisticated

Michael Murphy by Michael Murphy
20-09-2024 20:08
in Politics & Society
Reading Time: 8 mins read
A A
Welsh independence: a man kiteboarding above a Welsh landscape wind turbines on a hill in the distance

Photo by Marcus Woodbridge on Unsplash

Share on Bluesky

You can read part one in the series here.

One of the most common arguments used by Unionists against Welsh independence is that Wales cannot afford to pay its own way. They repeat that Wales receives £18bn a year as a ‘handout’ from the UK, and cannot survive without this ‘subsidy’. They overlook that Wales also generates taxes and revenue, collected directly by the UK, and the £18bn is largely a return of that.

However, it’s been difficult to refute such claims as there was long a shortage of reliable data on the economic performance of Wales. There’s a huge body of economic statistics and data published by the UK Government in its National Accounts – commonly referred to as ‘The Blue Book’ – but it’s difficult for the average person to follow, let alone extract the necessary data in a Welsh context.

Economic data for Wales

So it was a huge step forward when, in 2019, the Wales Governance Centre at Cardiff University analysed the available data and published the report Government Expenditure and Revenue Wales (or ‘GERW 2019’). The report attempted to present an objective estimate of how much is spent on public services in Wales, and how much tax revenue is generated to fund those services.

At first glance, the key findings were worrying. It was written that government expenditure in Wales exceeded revenue raised in Wales by £13.7bn, equivalent to 17% of the country’s gross domestic product (GDP). This is clearly unsustainable.

But while GERW 2019 was prepared with the best of intentions, it reflected a number of assumptions, which have since proven to be inappropriate or inaccurate. As a result, the report significantly underestimates the total tax revenue raised in Wales, while greatly overestimating the value of government expenditure.

The basic problem is that the report was based on UK Government accounting practices that don’t necessarily apportion costs where those costs were actually incurred. HS2 expenditure is a classic and well documented example of this, but there are many others. Nor was tax revenue correctly apportioned to where it was actually generated – for example, corporation tax.

A second problem is that the report outlined contemporary expenditure and revenue, not those of an independent Wales. GERW 2019 acknowledged that it described Wales as part of the UK, whereas an independent Wales would be free to set its own policies on expenditure and revenue, defence expenditure being one obvious example.

A fiscal deficit?

The Welsh Government established an Independent Commission on the Constitutional Future of Wales in 2021, to consider various options for the future governance of Wales, including independence. In 2022, a paper was commissioned by Plaid Cymru from Professor John Doyle of Dublin City University on the so-called fiscal deficit in Wales.

Doyle’s research challenged the findings of GERW 2019, concluding that the fiscal gap (or budget deficit) in the first few years of an independent Wales would be around £2.6bn. This would be equivalent to 3.4% of GDP, not the 17% stated in GERW.

The UK as a whole runs a budget deficit, which has varied from 2% to 5% in recent years, and nobody is suggesting that the UK cannot be independent because of this. Indeed the average budget deficit across the OECD group of developed countries is currently 3.2%, comparable to that of an independent Wales.

Doyle concluded that much of the discrepancy between the two findings is due to UK government accounting practices, which don’t reflect how revenue and expenditure would be accounted for between two independent countries. The Welsh Independent Commission took the Doyle Report into account in concluding that independence is a viable option for Wales.

There is also the matter of restrained economic policy. Both Ireland and Singapore were ridiculed at the time of their independence from the UK as being unsustainable. But they flourished once they were free to develop their own economies, and today are among the richest economies in the world. So an initial deficit of 3.4% could easily disappear if we implement realistic economic policies.

An independent Wales would not need to rely on a huge subsidy to survive. We would simply need to manage our finances as most other independent countries do.

The trouble with Tesco

Tesco is a successful supermarket chain operating across the UK. In 2018–19 it reported net UK profits of £1.716bn and paid tax of £413mn, including corporation tax of £302mn. All its tax revenue was recorded as being generated at its head office at Cheshunt in Hertfordshire.

Yet Tesco operates more than 20 supermarkets in Wales, all generating income and profits towards the corporate total. Assuming that Tesco’s activities are generally distributed in line with population, it’s fair to assume that a share of Tesco’s profits and tax liabilities would be generated in Wales.

Wales’s population in 2018–19 was 3.1mn, compared to the UK total of 66.2mn, or proportionally 4.7% by population. Wales’s GDP then was £72.7bn compared to the UK total of £2,230bn, proportionally 3.3% by GDP. Based on Wales having a 4.7% share of the UK population, it’s reasonable to assume that around £80mn of net profits would have been created by ‘Tesco Wales’, with a corresponding tax liability of £19mn in tax payments.

But none of this profit is attributed to Wales. It’s all recorded as being created in SE England. The same is true of almost all other companies operating on a UK-wide basis with their headquarters in England – usually London or SE England. The notable exception is Admiral Insurance, which is headquartered in Cardiff.

Expenditure and revenue

According to GERW 2019, Wales contributed £1,306mn in corporation tax in 2018–19, equivalent to 2.3% of the UK total. This is significantly less than would be expected if considered as a proportion of GDP (3.4%) or population (4.7%). The reason for this apparent shortfall is not lack of tax generation, but the accounting practice of assigning profit by head office location.

Based on the example of Tesco, Wales generates far more corporation tax than was declared in GERW. I estimate this to be somewhere between £1.93bn (if shared on a GDP basis) or £2.668bn (on a population basis). For sake of argument, I’ll split the difference and assume realistic Welsh corporation tax receipts of £2.3bn – an increase of £1bn on the GERW value.

GERW stated that Welsh taxpayers paid £4.93bn in income tax in 2018–19, equivalent to 2.7% of the UK total. While this is significantly less than the proportionate value for the UK, this may be a fair reflection of the low wages paid in Wales relative to the UK. Income tax is allocated based on the registered address of individual taxpayers, so I assume the GERW figures are a reasonable reflection of revenue generated in Wales.

In that same period, Welsh taxpayers paid £4.547bn in National Insurance (NI) contributions, equivalent to 3.5% of the UK value. The Welsh share is more proportionate than income tax, highlighting the regressive nature of NI, which is capped at higher salaries.

Economic geography and Welsh independence

While an individual’s NI contributions are allocated to the address of that individual and could be accepted as accurate, this isn’t the case for employer NI contributions, which again are allocated to their head office. These should be reallocated on a geographical basis to the address of individual employees. On that basis I estimate it would increase Welsh NI contributions by £600mn to around £5.2bn.

Similarly, the figures for capital gains tax and stamp duty associated with corporate activities are assigned on the basis of HQ location and understate the tax revenue generated in Wales. However, these are relatively small amounts and difficult to estimate.

GERW reported that Welsh taxpayers paid £6.389bn in VAT in 2018–19, equivalent to 4.5% of the UK total. VAT is assigned based on the geographical location of the activity conducted, which is in a similar proportion to population and therefore seems a realistic measure of economic activity.

Based on the data and assumptions above, I estimate that the government revenue generated by Wales in 2018–19 was actually around £28.750bn, an increase of £1.6bn compared to GERW figures. This is simply based on a reassessment of accounting practice, and doesn’t identify how an independent Wales may choose to adopt different tax policies and regimes in the future. I’ll examine such issues in part three of this series.


Infographics from Easyfundraising

We are registered with easyfundraising! 8,000 brands will donate to us for free every time you use it.

It’s super quick and easy to SIGN UP, and will never cost you anything whatsoever. It’s FREE for you and HUGE for us!


Tags: economicsindependence
Previous Post

Wales on Wednesday: back to school for Welsh Labour

Next Post

The beating hearts of South Wales Valleys towns left behind

Michael Murphy

Michael Murphy

Michael Murphy is a civil engineer from Cardiff. He has worked for the last 25 years building oil and gas projects around the world and is currently the Quality Director of a green hydrogen project in Saudi Arabia. He has a strong interest in energy and infrastructure projects, and is a member of Gwlad and a Director of YesCymru.

Related Posts

White concrete building with red and yellow flag on top under blue sky.during-daytime
Politics & Society

Spanish elections: a cultural view from the País Valencià, and parallels with Wales

by Joan Pedro-Carañana, Enrique Uribe Jongbloed and Toby Miller
9 November 2026
A garden filled with lots of different types of flowers.
Environment

A love lesson from the garden

by Martha Garcia
6 November 2026
Man chained to a heavy weight labelled Misogyny
Politics & Society

‘Good men’ and the misogyny they excuse

by Jack Meredith
5 November 2026 - Updated on 9 November 2026
Factories with smoke under a cloudy sky.
Environment

Dan Ashby and Lucy Taylor unearth a toxic legacy

by Brian McHugh
4 November 2026
Senior woman paying bills.
Economy

Growing older should not mean going without

by Martha Garcia
3 November 2026
Next Post
Valleys: a view of and in mountains and a winding road near Treorchy, with green aurora in the sky

The beating hearts of South Wales Valleys towns left behind

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

BROWSE BY TAGS

austerity Austerity Project Brexit campaign climate change community Cost of living Covid Cymraeg democracy devolution economy education energy environment equality events general election health history identity inclusion independence international journalism mental health older people opinion party politics Plaid Cymru Poetry Sunday politics public health public services research Senedd South Wales Welsh culture Welsh Government Welsh heritage Welsh history Welsh language Welsh poetry Welsh writers Westminster
Bylines Cymru

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Cymru and beyond.

Bylines Cymru is a trading brand of Bylines Networks Limited which is separate to, but allied with, Byline Times.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Authors and editors
  • Complaints
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Privacy
  • Network Map
  • Network RSS Feeds
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Download the Bylines Network App

© 2023-2026 Bylines Cymru. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9712

No Result
View All Result
  • Politics & Society
    • Devolution
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Media
    • Trade
    • Westminster
  • Arts & Culture
  • Hiraeth
  • Voices | Lleisiau
    • Deialog | Interview
    • Editorial
    • Gwalia | History
    • Opinion
    • Poetry
  • Sports & Leisure

Newsletter sign up

CROWDFUNDER

© 2023-2026 Bylines Cymru. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9712