In 1963, the Beeching cuts were made to bring down the debt of British Rail. This led to 189 stations in Wales being marked for closure on top of the 166 Welsh stations and halt-stops that were planned for closure even prior to Beeching. The resultant lines left in Wales seemed to be based on profitability or industrial use. Today, for passengers and freight both, Wales is left with a fragmented rail system.
A former Arriva Trains Wales manager said that one line, for example, was saved because of its industrial activity: “Although there were a lot of local protests from people as one would expect, I think the traffic that came from the power station saved the Conwy Valley line.” No surprise, then, that the slate epicentre of Blaenau Ffestiniog maintained its route out of Wales, as did the coal-rich valleys of the South. According to some, the Heart of Wales line only exists because it passed through many election-tipping seats.
A fragmented rail system
There are no north-south rail connections in Wales but there are a grand total of eight crossings into England. Routes don’t seem to match up with population density, either. If they did, surely Aberystwyth would be connected to the southwest and Bangor would be connected to somewhere around the Llŷn Peninsula. Bangor to Porthmadog by train is currently not an option, and even a bus journey on that route takes around 35 minutes longer than by car. Cardiff to Aberystwyth currently takes two to three hours longer by public transport than by car, hardly convenient or in keeping with a move to a greener future.
This map of current rail routes in Wales also identifies pre-Beeching routes for reopening. It is by the campaign group Traws Link Cymru, which reflects that: “Mid- and West Wales are currently some of the most deprived areas of the United Kingdom and, indeed, of Western Europe. Yet this region has considerable potential …”. The group asserts that “new railway lines between Aberystwyth and Carmarthen and Afon Wen and Bangor could provide the stimulus needed to kickstart economic and social regeneration throughout the region. Moreover, a railway line running from Bangor in the north to Carmarthen in the south would not only provide an important transport link between industrial South Wales and the rural north, but it would also bind the country together to produce a more integrated Wales.”

This map by Mark Barry incorporates his recommendations of Bangor-Porthmadog and Builth Wells-Caersws connections, which include partly reopened and partly new lines. Barry is Professor of Practice in Connectivity at Cardiff University and a Strategic Advisor to Transport for Wales via his consulting company. He conceived and has been working on the South Wales Metro project since 2010, and has helped establish metro development programmes across Wales.

The great Welsh train robbery
As of 2019, 69% of Welsh rail journeys occurred exclusively within Wales and 7.2% involved London. Despite this, the Welsh Affairs Committee estimates that Welsh taxpayers are being billed £5bn for the development of London-Manchester High-Speed Rail 2 (HS2). The project exists only in England with not a single inch of track or improvement in Wales. As consolation, Wales has received only £755mn from the UK government, following an increase in the UK Department for Transport budget.
To add to our misery, Northern Powerhouse rail (NPR) is likely set to spend yet another £1bn, according to Wales Online journalist Will Hayward. Money which should be spent in Wales is yet again classed as an England and Wales project, with NPR benefitting only a small number of Welsh rail commuters to Northern England. The big question is; why are Welsh taxpayers footing the bill for two major projects constructed exclusively in England, and at the expense of our own Welsh national rail service? And what’s the Senedd doing about it?
If Network Rail enhancement spending had been devolved from 2011-12 to 2018-19, Cardiff University says that Wales would have had another £514mn to spend on rail. Labour had the chance to devolve Welsh rail during Gordon Brown’s tenure up until 2010. Despite Scottish rail infrastructure being devolved in 2005 and warnings from Plaid Cymru, this never happened. It’s unlikely that Mark Drakeford or transport minister Lee Waters would own up to that. With no promise of rail devolution or a HS2 consequential from either Sunak or Starmer, Welsh rail could be at risk of persistent underfunding.
This year, all four parties of the Senedd agreed on a motion brought by Plaid Cymru that Wales should get proportional funding for HS2. On this, Welsh Conservatives leader Andrew RT Davies is going against the position of his own party in Westminster, including the Secretary of State for Wales, David TC Davies. This is perhaps an attempt to project appeal as a “more Welsh” party, particularly following a series of unprecedented Tory scandals. Nevertheless, all four Senedd leaders have chosen to be on the right side of history this time.
What could the money be spent on?
Adding up this chronic underfund, Wales seems to be down by a vast sum of around £5.8bn. This is in addition to a £200mn annual drain on the South Wales economy caused by HS2, as estimated by the UK government itself back in 2013. A decade later, it’s possible the impact could be even worse.
To put this into perspective, reopening the Carmarthen to Aberystwyth line would cost around £775mn according to the Welsh government, revised to £620mn by Traws Link Cymru / Ymgyrch Rheilffordd Gorllewin Cymru. In addition, the route could attract half a million passengers annually by 2027, if their plans were implemented. Linking the whole west coast by reopening the Bangor-Afon Wen line could bring North and South together like never before and provide a significant boost to regional economies.
Exciting new developments in the pipeline include the electrified South Wales Metro from Bridgend all the way to Monmouthshire, due to be rolled out by 2024 with costs expected at around £1.6bn. The Swansea Bay and West Wales Metro and the North Wales Metro are also in the works. The Welsh Government has hinted at a “West Wales extension”, which could link Bangor to Aberystwyth, but this is described as a “longer term” project beyond 2029. Although Plaid Cymru has been consistently encouraging, particularly via the co-operation agreement commitment, the Welsh Government seriously needs to pull its socks up.
Integrating North and South Wales rail along with three new metros could revitalise public transport, forming a truly national Welsh rail service, and one to be proud of. Wales can of course achieve all this, with or without Westminster, but £6bn more in the pot would not go amiss, and is only fair.






