The Welsh Government has clearly signalled that it’s about to make major changes to the way its 20mph default speed limit on urban roads is implemented. The new First Minister and Welsh Labour leadership have said they “hold their hands up” and that guidance “has to be corrected”.
This is a hugely important decision, and not just because of the 20mph issue itself. The matter sits firmly on the boundary between evidenced policy-making on the one hand and populism on the other.
The evidence base for 20mph
The original decision on a default 20mph limit rather than 30mph was firmly based on evidence. Its justification was the well-documented fact that reducing urban speed limits reduces pollution and casualties – which also saves the NHS money – and makes neighbourhoods better places to live. These benefits accrue without, in many cases, causing significant differences to journey times.
So the evidence base is substantial and solid. The implementation of the change was in the hands of local authorities based on Welsh Government guidelines. Those are likely to be the focus of the likely forthcoming change to Welsh Government policy.
Opposition to the 20mph default was based on ideology and political gamesmanship. It leaned on the use of misleading language like “blanket” implementation. It used misinterpreted figures based on long-term economic appraisal of the policy as a basis for massively exaggerated claims about the “cost” to the Welsh economy. These were taken out of context and used without any reference to the known benefits. The approach replaced evidence with meaningless ideological buzz-words like “woke”.
And at the heart of it was a clash between the private – drivers who demand the right to drive as they please – against the public: people who live in affected communities, and especially those without access to a car. This may have gone largely unspoken, but it was always a debate about privilege as much as anything.
A failure of nerve
So, as Welsh ministers prepare to change the policy, what has changed? Certainly not the evidence base. Although it is too early to make a full evaluation, such evidence as there is appears to show that the policy is working, in a way that is consistent with the evidence from elsewhere.
If there are issues with individual roads, changes rest with the relevant local authorities. And the Welsh Government has committed to reviews in light of the evidence. There is already a mechanism in place to review and deal with any flawed local decisions.
It is difficult to avoid the conclusion, then, that the latest policy U-turn results from a failure of nerve in the face of a populist campaign. If so, that’s a considerable problem.
If we have learned one thing about right-wing populism in the last decade – from Brexit in particular – it is the danger of appeasing it. The Brexit process showed that the old British constitutional methodologies of conventions, ‘gentlemen’s agreements’, and compromise no longer work in the face of a determined populism that claims to represent “the will of the people”. Any concessions are banked, and more are then demanded.
Moreover, when you appease populists, you allow them to set the agenda. The Labour Party should have learned this in the recent by-election in Uxbridge. Panicked by Conservative attacks on Sadiq Khan’s London-wide ULEZ proposals, they conceded the argument – and promptly lost an election they should have won. They allowed populist claims to define the debate, to their cost.
Empowering populists
Welsh Labour’s capitulation on 20mph has given the Welsh Conservatives licence to say they were right all along. The latter have been handed control of the debate and seen their aggressive populism legitimised. And that is a very dangerous thing to have happened. Once a progressive party appeases populists it cannot win, because the ground it has conceded is fundamentally about how politics are done.
Democracy is often about doing the right thing when it isn’t popular, and being able to explain your decisions to the electorate. In a world facing the existential threat of climate change, and in the face of well-funded climate denial, it’s probably the most important challenge democratic that politicians face.
In the case of 20mph, the Welsh Government’s apparent capitulation gives a populist Conservative opposition – one that progressive opinion tends to regard as a bit of a joke – control of a debate in which evidence should have been settled. It has empowered them.
Vaughan Gething is just beginning his term of office as First Minister, already facing a scandal, and a 2026 Senedd election against a background of Labour being in office in Westminster. Is this really the road he wants to take right now?







