• Contact
  • About
DONATE TO BYLINES CYMRU
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
Bylines Cymru
  • Home
  • Politics & Society
    • Devolution
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Europe
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Media
    • Trade
    • Westminster
  • Arts & Culture
  • Hiraeth
  • Voices
    • Deialog | Interview
    • Editorial
    • Gwalia | History
    • Opinion
    • Poetry
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics & Society
    • Devolution
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Europe
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Media
    • Trade
    • Westminster
  • Arts & Culture
  • Hiraeth
  • Voices
    • Deialog | Interview
    • Editorial
    • Gwalia | History
    • Opinion
    • Poetry
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
Bylines Cymru
Home Voices | Lleisiau Opinion

What next for Wales?

The United part of the United Kingdom isn’t working for Wales, says Ethan Jones. It’s time we had a different democratic model.

Ethan JonesbyEthan Jones
19-04-2023 19:09 - Updated on 25-04-2023 11:40
in Opinion, Voices | Lleisiau
Reading Time: 6 mins read
A A
London, by Plebo

Illustration by Plebo

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Is the here and now in Wales as good as it gets for us? It’s hard to find anyone arguing with enthusiasm that the answer is, “Yes”. A clear majority are dissatisfied with the current political system in the United Kingdom as a whole.

This is evidenced by the World Values Survey finding that only one in every six members of the British public is “very satisfied” with how UK democracy operates. To put this in perspective; that’s on a par with Vladimir Putin’s Russia. So it’s only natural to be asking, when it comes to a democratic model, “What next for Wales?”

Confederalism

That question seems to have been near the forefront of debate over the last couple of weeks. A raft of arguments have been put forward by a diverse array of activists, commentators, and journalists in a string of articles and other output, some from as far afield as Australia.

One democratic model put forward for a future Wales is ‘confederalism’. This is a system in which a union of states sees each member retaining some independent control over both internal and external affairs. However, for international purposes each state is treated separately. Now, you might argue that persuading the majority of Wales to vote for independence is a challenging enough prospect. So how do supporters of confederalism think persuading the majority of voters in Wales, Scotland, Northern Ireland, and England to back this idea is a more realistic prospect?

In short; it isn’t. Westminster, whether blue or red, has made it clear it’s not in favour of any more substantive devolution. That is not likely to change. Both shades at Westminster are content to ignore the democratic mandate given to the SNP by the Scottish public. What chance is there of Westminster agreeing to surrender power in order to enter into an equal confederation with the Senedd, Holyrood, and Stormont (provided the three devolved nations are even willing, of course)?

A federal UK

Confederalism just isn’t going to happen. In my view, this is another attempt by soft-leaning Unionists to keep the Union going. Don’t get me wrong, I believe the ideals behind it are genuine and heartfelt, but I don’t think they are realistic. Let’s not forget that England is by far the largest country in the UK, by population. Will England choose to put itself in a position in which it could be vetoed by Wales, Scotland, or Northern Ireland? I doubt it.

UK population 2021
UK populations at 2021. Sourced from ons.gov.uk

Another democratic model put forward for Wales is that of a federal UK. You can see variants of this system in Canada and the USA, for example, where governing power is shared between national and provincial or state governments.

This idea hinges upon England being carved up into smaller regions, along the lines of the old regionalised system for the European Union elections. Would England agree to this? Again, I doubt it. My scepticism is backed up by the fact that North East England voted against a devolution deal in 2004 by a massive margin. And ultimately, would there ever be a government elected to Westminster on a manifesto pledge of breaking up England? Of course not.

For me, independence provides the most favourable route to securing a future in which Wales can thrive. Look at Slovenia for inspiration. Yes, some of you may scoff at that. But, Slovenia has just surpassed the UK in terms of average standard of living.

The most democratic model

Slovenia gained its independence in 1991. At that time, Wales was significantly better off than Slovenia; now the opposite is true. Independence gave the people of Slovenia the freedom to adopt policies that worked for them specifically, proving that a smaller economy is more agile and better equipped to serve its population. Slovenia spent the decades prior to its independence as part of Yugoslavia and, prior to that, centuries as part of the Austrian Empire. As with Wales, Slovenia had been ‘unified’ with its much larger neighbours for centuries. But in the end, was it too small? Was it too poor, for independence? Evidently not,

Wales too could take this path, decoupling itself from a union that simply isn’t working in its best interests. Some 200,000 children in Wales are living in poverty; 90,000 of those children are classified as living in absolute poverty. By that measure alone, is this a union that’s working for us? My answer is emphatically NO.

I believe our energies are better utilised in pushing for independence and securing for Wales the powers it needs to thrive, rather than a desperate (albeit well-meaning) attempt to save the union. Neither confederalism or federalism offer a solution. I think the time has come to put our hands up and say; the Union isn’t working. Westminster doesn’t work for Wales. Park it.

Westminster is all about clinging to a past that no longer exists. Independence for Wales is about the future, and the positivity and potential that could be brought about. We’re neither too small nor too poor.


Editor’s note: it is the editorial policy of Bylines Cymru to publish all arguments and opinions for, against, or agnostic about Welsh independence as long as they are within the bounds of civil discourse. In this way we hope to provide an open platform for discussion of the subject from all perspectives.


We need your help!

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication, but we still have considerable costs.

If you believe in what we do, please consider subscribing to our digital Bylines Gazette from as little as £2 a month 🙏

Tags: democracyidentityWelsh independenceYesCymru
Previous Post

Rough Cut: Netflix’s first Welsh language series

Next Post

What Thatcher did for Wales

Ethan Jones

Ethan Jones

Ethan Jones is Director (North Wales) of YesCymru.

Related Posts

New mum and baby
Voices | Lleisiau

When being a new mum feels overwhelming: expert advice on what you need to know

byAmy Brown
26 September 2023
Owain Glyndŵr’s banner
Poetry

Welsh Poetry Sunday: great men of Wales

byArthur Cole
24 September 2023
Man seeking therapy
Voices | Lleisiau

Want to start therapy, but not sure what type? Here are four to consider

byLauren Copeland
23 September 2023
Looking in a rearview mirror
Opinion

What does the 20mph debate say about Wales?

byEthan Jones
22 September 2023
Ballot papers
Opinion

We should call electoral misrepresentation what it is: a fraud

byRichard Jenkins
20 September 2023
Next Post
Margaret Thatcher, 1981

What Thatcher did for Wales

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

Subscribe to our newsletters
CHOOSE YOUR NEWS
Follow us on social media
CHOOSE YOUR PLATFORMS
Download our app
ALL OF BYLINES IN ONE PLACE
Subscribe to our gazette
CONTRIBUTE TO OUR SUSTAINABILITY
Make a monthly or one-off donation
DONATE NOW
Help us with our hosting costs
SIGN UP TO SITEGROUND
We are always looking for citizen journalists
WRITE FOR US
Volunteer as an editor, in a technical role, or on social media
VOLUNTEER FOR US
Something else?
GET IN TOUCH
Previous slide
Next slide

LATEST

Looking out over Wales

Zen and the art of Welsh independence

28 September 2023
Buckingham Palace guard

The Diary of a Secret Royal: dodgy dispatches from a sly and funny fellow

28 September 2023
New mum and baby

When being a new mum feels overwhelming: expert advice on what you need to know

26 September 2023
Senedd Siambr / Chamber

Empowering Welsh democracy: the Senedd Cymru (Members and Elections) Bill explained

25 September 2023

MOST READ

No Content Available

BROWSE BY TAGS

accountability austerity Brexit campaign citizen journalism climate change community Cost of living Covid Cymraeg democracy devolution economy education environment EU Europe events film history freeports health history identity inclusion independence journalism Language mental health monarchy poetry Poetry Sunday politics poverty psychology public health public services refugees Refugee Week sustainability Welsh Welsh Government Welsh history Welsh poetry Westminster YesCymru
Bylines Cymru

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Cymru and beyond.

Bylines Cymru is a trading brand of Bylines Network Limited, which is a partner organisation to Byline Times.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Authors
  • Complaints
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Network Map
  • Network RSS Feeds
  • Privacy

© 2023 Bylines Cymru. Powerful Citizen Journalism

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics & Society
    • Devolution
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Media
    • Trade
    • Westminster
  • Arts & Culture
  • Hiraeth
  • Voices | Lleisiau
    • Deialog | Interview
    • Editorial
    • Gwalia | History
    • Opinion
    • Poetry
  • Sports & Leisure
  • Newsletter sign up
  • Authors
CROWDFUNDER

© 2023 Bylines Cymru. Powerful Citizen Journalism

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In