Westminster is terrified of Welsh and Scottish independence because of its reliance on our energy. Westminster covered up knowledge of the imminent bounty from Scotland’s oil in the 1970s. Now it’s wind and clean energy on the table.
It’s a blistering irony that the neoliberal UK – which seems set to continue after this election, and with its willing agency trundling on in Wales – is indeed providing the wealth creation opportunities it claims … but for the social democracies of Scandinavia and elsewhere. Whose companies, often government-owned, benefit from energy developments in our waters and on our land. We should be making the most of our clean energy largesse. But there seem to be more mugs in Wales than you’ll find in IKEA.
Keeping the lights on
In this general election, Labour is offering nothing on energy for Wales. It doesn’t offer devolution of the Crown Estate, and there’s no reward for or even recognition of the huge role Wales plays in keeping the lights on in the UK.
There’s just the prospect of having an ill-defined GB Energy foisted on us. And an expectation that Wales will continue to play the role of sacrificial lamb in the attempt to deliver Westminster’s ill thought-out net zero plan. Extracting energy from Wales while taking Wales for granted, for meagre climate gain and a pile-on of unnecessary pylons.
Ignoring growing calls to devolve the Crown Estate – which would only be fair, as it was done in and for Scotland in 2017 – is a tacit admission of how London and the South East of England, in particular, are reliant on the supply of electricity from Wales. We can’t possibly let the Welsh control the source of energy! The pylons march west to east, one-way traffic only.
Labour makes a big noise about growth, data centres, AI, and the like. This is a model of ‘growth’ that relies on and demands the energy of Wales and Scotland. No energy, no growth. And there stalls the economic plan.
The brass ring just out of reach
There are those who say not to rock the boat. They assert that we can accrue economic benefits to Wales through the current order. Really? Then take a look at Finland, which eyes renewables and hydrogen as a staggering €33bn added-value opportunity for its economy, with up to 115,000 new jobs, by 2035. Or consider Denmark, which has a booming clean energy sector. Or the Netherlands, which just auctioned subsidy-free offshore wind. And so on.
The economic prize would be orders of magnitude greater than what’s currently on offer, were Wales to set the rules of the game of energy first and foremost for our own benefit. And we would have willing buyers for the considerable excess clean energy that we can produce. That is usually a normal state of affairs for any country, yet we’re denied a look-in by the State we’re in.
Yes, that scenario still means working with big international players, with their knowledge and capital to match ours for mutual benefit. But it could be carried out on the clear understanding that transformational benefits will accrue to Wales from the bounty.
Wales would be in a very strong position to rapidly develop our own clean growth economy. And we could generate further wealth by supplying energy to England and continental Europe. We could use that wealth to reinvest in our own country, our culture, and our communities. Why on earth aren’t we doing this?
The energy of power
But such partnerships can only be achieved as equals. As sovereign nations. Otherwise Westminster will claim the bounty and leave us with just the crumbs. We can supply energy and we can cut a fair deal with those who demand it, but only if we’re in a position of power in both senses of the word.
Wales has the energy but not the powers. We need to cut out the Westminster middleman, who helps himself to such a hefty slice of our resources.
Many comparisons are being made with the 1997 UK general election just now, for obvious reasons. But this is more like 1979. There’s discontent across the country, and little apparent enthusiasm for the main political alternative. A known energy bounty is about to happen – but which bypasses the countries that would supply that energy. And there’s an appetite for real change among the public. But instead there is a conspiracy of silence over public finances.
And we know what happened after 1979.
We in Wales have been taken for granted for far too long. It’s time for real change, not slogan-change. And for holding whoever forms the next UK Government to account – in Wales’ best interests, not Westminster’s.






