Last month, the UK Government redefined extremism. It is now held to include “advancement of any ideology which aims to overturn or undermine the UK’s system of parliamentary democracy, its institutions and values”.
So, as a campaigner for Welsh independence, will I – and others of my ilk – be perceived as extremists? Does that definition include those who oppose Westminster rule because it is fundamentally unaccountable to the people of Wales?
The real enemy within
March marked the 40th anniversary of the Miners’ strike, a seismic event that changed the political course of the British state. The current dysfunctionality of the UK did not begin in 2010, 2016, or 2019. It can be traced back to the 1980s when a Westminster government began a programme of privatisation while doing all it could to undermine organised working-class communities.
Margaret Thatcher famously said of the colliers’ strike: “We had to fight the enemy without in the Falklands. We always have to be aware of the enemy within, which is much more difficult to fight and more dangerous to liberty.”
The prime minister who quoted St Francis of Assisi in promising to bring unity and hope did exactly the opposite, as disclosed by the opening of classified documents of that time. Using the police force, the security services’ dirty tricks department, court actions, and the right wing press, she ensured the mass subversion of democratic liberties. The pillars of a democratic state were abused and used against its own people.
Defining extremism
Fast forward 40 years or so, and Michael Gove – Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, a vacuous job title if ever there was one – unveiled the Westminster government’s new definition of extremism. We know how concerned Prime Minister Rishi Sunak is about ‘extremism’. He told us, in that Friday night panic attack on the podium outside Number 10. Whatever you think of George Galloway, he won the Rochdale by-election democratically; more than can be said for Sunak.
This new definition is so … ahem … extreme that even Priti Patel and two other former Tory Home Secretaries have voiced concerns about it. The matter is not being debated in the House of Commons – it was just rolled out as ‘guidance’ without democratic scrutiny or accountability. Unusually, without even any consultation.
Under this guidance, certain groups will be blocked from government funding and meeting officials. It’s … er … extremely broad, shifting the previous focus on action to spotlight ideology.
I am Spartacus
So does the new definition include those who would see that system replaced with a dynamic and representative form of Welsh democracy? One that actually reflects the needs and aspirations of the Welsh people?
It has become eminently clear that the rot set in a long time ago within the institutions of Westminster. Lovers of the ‘small state’ – that is, a dismantled and asset-stripped state – and neoliberalism did a fine job of undermining that which they professed to love so much. Their extreme ideology is a parasite infiltrating the body politic then eating away at it from within. It is hollowing it out until there is barely anything left to preserve or rebuild.
As supporters of Welsh independence, will we now be perceived as some of the many new “enemies within”? Is it extreme to want a fairer society and a sovereign Welsh state? To want our natural resources to be harnessed and used for the benefit of those communities that never recovered from Thatcher’s actions in the 1980s? Is this our “I am Spartacus” moment within the Welsh independence movement?







