The village of Fairbourne on the Welsh coast has something in common with the Cocos Islands of the Indian Ocean, some 7,500 miles to the southeast. Both communities are threatened by rises in sea level.
In both cases, governments have determined that the cost of improving sea defences is unacceptably high. So over time there will be a ‘managed retreat’ from the threat, necessitating moving people permanently away from their homes and communities.
The All-Red Line
I became aware of the Cocos – officially known as the Territory of Cocos (Keeling) Islands – many years ago, when I heard Ken Tidey’s personal account of his time on the islands and the reason behind it. I was in the front room of Ken and Nesta Tidey’s home in Porthcawl at the time.
The Cocos are a group of 27 islands in the eastern Indian Ocean on two low-lying coral atolls, with a maximum elevation of 5 metres above sea level. The current population of around 600 lives on two islands, West Island and Home Island. The Cocos are an external territory of Australia, lying 2,290 miles (3,685 km) west of Darwin, Northern Territory, about halfway between Australia and Sri Lanka.
Charles Darwin visited the Cocos briefly in 1836, while traveling on the Beagle. He observed that coral reefs continued growing after the seamounts that had initially supported them subsided. He also observed undercutting of coconut trees and shoreline erosion. There’s evidence elsewhere in the Indian Ocean that coral atolls have some built-in resilience to sea-level rise, and can continue to grow naturally.
By 1911 the Cocos had become a hub on the All-Red Line communication network in the Indian Ocean, much of which was by undersea cable. It linked British Empire countries worldwide. The network had such redundancy built in that it would have taken 49 interruptions to prevent all communication by cable to the UK.
Battles of Cocos
Cables ran from Direction Island – one to Mauritius and on to South Africa, one to Perth and Australia. In 1914, the German light cruiser SMS Emden sent a party ashore in an attempt to disable the telegraph cable station there. It was able to send a distress signal to Australia, and HMAS Sydney was sent to investigate. After a short battle, the Emden was badly damaged and beached on North Keeling Island.
The Allied forces occupied the islands for most of the second world war. The cable station on Direction Island was also attacked by Japanese warships in 1942. Decoy fires, and a false radio message saying the cable station had been destroyed, convinced Japanese forces that the station had been disabled. But in fact, though damaged, it continued to operate in secret.
Which brings us to Ken Tidey and his deployment to the tropical Indian Ocean. Kenneth John Tidey grew up near Llangennith, on the rural Gower peninsula on the South Wales coast. He trained in a secretarial school in Swansea and had beautiful copperplate handwriting, which he sometimes demonstrated to me after he’d done some preliminary hand-steadying exercises.
When the second world war broke out, an underage Ken volunteered and was accepted by the Royal Navy. Possibly because of his secretarial skills, he was posted for radio telegraphy training at a centre in Brighton. He was then selected for more specialised training in Eastbourne, where he acquired skills in intercepting and recording Japanese Morse code, used to eavesdrop on enemy naval transmissions in the Indian Ocean.
When his training was over, and still in his late teens or early 20s, he was posted to the remote Cocos Islands.
Remember them
Because of their location on the All-Red Line linking Australia to the UK, the Cocos were a strategic listening post from which radio transmissions intercepted from Japanese shipping could be recorded by skilled telegraphers like Ken. The intelligence gained was relayed by cable, enabling radio silence to be maintained. Messages were interpreted in the UK by experts fluent in Japanese, and evaluated by intelligence officers.
Nowadays, Fairbourne and the Cocos are considered unworthy of investment to protect them from rising sea levels. Would they have suffered the same fate had they been located on the North Sea coast of the Netherlands?
At a time when major tech companies – including Google, Meta, Amazon, and Microsoft – are planning their own global undersea cable networks, it may be prudent to maintain links via the Cocos hub, known as the Oman-Australia cable. It’s still active and operational, and is one of 15 known connections linking Australia to the world.
There may be an independent connectivity justification for maintaining a presence (hopefully as large a presence as possible) on the Cocos. There’s also a climate argument for monitoring Indian Ocean Dipole (IOD) temperature variations across the ocean from the Islands. The IOD, like the better-known ENSO (EL Niño) variations in the Pacific, profoundly influences the Australian climate.
I’m minded to paraphrase RS Thomas regarding Ken Tidey, his generation, and the Cocos Islands themselves. “Remember them, then, for they too are winners of wars.”







