It is a truism of governance that it involves difficult decisions. I was a policy civil servant working in Whitehall – and Brussels – for a quarter of a century. Most of my time was spent working on transport policy. I learned early on that policymaking involves difficult trade-offs, due to conflicts between different policy objectives. Between economic growth and the environment, or local and national policy; between communities and the traffic that passes through them.
If there is one thing we in Wales have learned in the past year, having adopted a 20mph default urban speed limit, it’s how emotive those decisions can be. So when there’s a key political issue with an obvious and straightforward solution, yet the entire political class seems to be in denial about it, that tells you something important about the politics of that issue. ‘Stop the boats’ is a prime example.
Stop the stop the boats
The Conservative government in Westminster has placed stopping small boats carrying refugees across the English channel among its top priorities. And it has devised a policy of deporting asylum seekers to Rwanda in response (though the groups affected are not in fact the same people). The opposition Labour Party is equally keen to stop the boats, and has announced proposals that amount to an enhanced security regime. Both rightly emphasise the role of criminal gangs in the crossings.
The answer to the problem is simple, and political leaders surely know it. It is to create safe and legal routes for asylum seekers, and take up the French government’s offer of processing facilities in France. At a stroke, the UK would meet its international obligations, the market for illegal crossings would be eliminated, and processing could be managed far more efficiently. Stop the boats? It’s a no-brainer.
Yet neither political party is prepared to do it. The Conservative government persists with its absurd, inhumane plans to fly refugees to Rwanda. It’s even passed a law to state that, regardless of any evidence in the real world, Rwanda is a safe destination. It’s spent enormous amounts of money and taken the UK to the brink of lawlessness to push its pet scheme. Labour has dismissed the Rwanda scheme as impractical – although stops short of arguing that it’s wrong in principle – but its proposals are focused on security and deterrence.
The conclusion seems obvious. Neither party really wants to stop the boats.
Moving in flimsy vessels
In my view, this is because both parties are more interested in the political narratives. The Conservatives want to maintain a narrative of an independent Britain, ‘sovereignty’ restored, that can control its borders. Their pretence that the arrival of people on small boats represents an existential threat to the UK is part of this. It both feeds on the right wing populism unleashed by Brexit and engages in a death-match with the true Brexit believers of the Reform Party.
Labour’s position seems to me a little different. Traumatised by its loss of what it regards as its heartlands in the 2019 general election, it has chosen to appease what it believes to be the Brexiter instincts of the people who deserted it. Like the Conservatives – who made it a political red line that there shall be no return to freedom of movement – Labour seems reluctant to accept that the sovereignty promised by Brexiters is illusory.
And neither party appears to believe it has anything to lose by ‘othering’ the desperate and wretched people undertaking that dangerous Channel crossing in flimsy boats.
Populist storytelling
On this issue, it seems clear – to me, at least – that both Labour and the Conservatives are in the narrative business, as distinct from the business of good governance. (While being aware that only one is in actual power). The UK faces unprecedented economic and social pressures. There has been a precipitate collapse of living standards and public services in recent years, yet neither party appears willing to challenge the underlying assumptions of austerity that have brought us here.
Populist narratives are what politicians do when the real world is too puzzling, too complex, too inconvenient. Inventing populist narratives that actually prevent you from solving the problem you claim to be concerned with is surely the most dangerous and futile form of politics.
The politics of small boats is as powerful a metaphor as you could find for a political system in its death throes, with right wing populists being empowered by its irrational drama. Where are the empirical, rational, truth-telling politics that stand against such populism to come from?






